5

The Clay Court Affair Part II

Posted March 4th, 2005 in Hubbub by M

Well, as weeks go, this one has been an interesting one. Most of you seem to feel deeply in the matter of the Nation’s usage of material sourced from here. I seem to have become an unofficial revolutionary of sorts!

The Global Voices have raised the issue in this post (Good looking out Ory)

Let me answer the most asked questions today.

Q: Did you know your material was going to be used?
A: No. I was just as surprised

Q: Did you write or call The Columnist concerning this matter?
A: Yes. Details of our communication are here

Q: Have any of the Nation’s editors been in touch with you?
A: No.

Q: What do you think of all the furore that has been raised
A: Well, to be honest, I didn’t think quite so many people passed through here! I’m flattered.

Q: Will this affair make you reconsider putting your writings online
A: NO!

I’ve also just received a mail from the extremely energetic Truphena

From: Truphena
To: M, Lucy Oriang (Managing Editor)
Cc: Clay Muganda (Columnist) , Betty Muriuki (Friday Nation Editor), Charles Onyango Obbo (Managing Editor, Products)

I notice with disappointment that in your Friday 4 March issue of the Daily Nation you have failed to mention the matter of sourcing material from alternative sources and failing to credit the source, as was the case with the issue of Clay Court on the 25th of February.

I regret to say that this matter cannot be swept under the carpet and ignored. Continued silence will only lead to further erosion of the reputation of the Nation, which continues to happen the longer you ignore the matter

For instance the matter has now grown beyond the active web community of Kenyan diaspora, and has now caught the attention of the international web fraternity and is the subject of discussion in The Global Village, a Harvard University sponsored initiative. The issue is raised here http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/globalvoices/index.php?p=60, and again the credibility of the paper is taking a beating

I believe that the Kenyan Media is signatory to the Ethical codes of the World Free Press, as outlined in the East Africa Free Press Assembly Nairobi, Kenya 2000, and Ethics in the media has been discussed at length.

My interest in this matter lies in the fact that:
- Such practice is harmful to the Nation, and the Kenyan media at large, because if they lose credibility their role as a watchdog of society will suffer
- Such practice will stile the development of alternative modes of expression, such as web logs, which again is bad for the public
- Such practices will also stifle the abundance of talent out there who write not for the money but for the love if it.

I hope the Nation will at the end of the day do the right thing, not only for its own benefit, but that of the media as a whole.

Regards

Truphena

The responses to this ought to make for some interesting reading. I’ll keep you posted

Nyota Ndogo – Mambo Kombo
  • http://kenyanpundit.com Kenyan Pundit

    Truphena, keep up the doggedness.

  • http://bangaiza.kylix.co.ke maitha

    actually the Nation should do much better and discipline this Clay character . there was one such case in Zimbabwe where a journalist was suspended and demoted after copying Catherine Awour’s ( also a Nation journalist) work . see below

    The Standard – Zim
    8/2/04

    Another Zimpapers Editor in trouble for plagiarism
    By Our Own Staff

    PHYLLIS Kachere, the desk editor of Metro magazine, a supplement in the State-controlled weekly, The Sunday Mail, was last week suspended from the paper for one week and demoted after she plagiarised an article from Kenya”s Nation newspaper”s Saturday Magazine.

    Kachere, who authors Steaming Off a weekly light hearted column in the paper wrote an article published on January 11 entitled: “Learn the Very Simple Art of Charming Ladies, which extensively copied a story by Kenyan journalist Catherine Awuor of the Saturday Magazine.

    Awour”s story appeared in the Kenyan magazine”s issue of December 27 last year.

    Kachere”s and Awuor”s work entitled “Help! Can”t get a girlfriend shows that The Sunday Mail”s article is not original and is an exact copy of Awour”s.

    In one section, Awuor writes: “I have seen a friend of mine fall for the line, “you look familiar, were we in the same high school; she was in a girls” only school but he got her talking”.”

    Kachere on the other hand wrote: “I once fell for the line, “you look familiar, were we in the same high school? The guy got me talking and that result got me in a two-year affair.

    In another part, Awuor writes : “Today”s article is for the man whose idea of dinner is Kenchic take away (a popular Kenyan restaurant)…, Kachere wrote: “Today”s article is for the man whose idea of dinner is Cresta Mbare (some eating spot in Harare”s Mbare high-density suburb.)

    Awuor continues: “To give details of the evening don”t sms. A text that reads: “W 8 4 me@simas”. It just won”t do.. Kachere wrote: “W 8 4 me @ KFC just won”t do.

    Last year two other Zimpapers employees Tim Chigodo and Shingai Rukwata Ndoro also got in trouble for fraudulently plagiarising other journalists” work.

    Chigodo was forced to quit while Rukwata Ndoro, a freelance journalist who also worked in the newspaper”s circulation department, was transferred. He has since left Zimpapers.

  • http://spideyfun.blogspot.com nick

    initially i was inciting u to just ask me and to make a certain phone call…and someone would get a dead cold fish on there certain desk….before sleepin wit the fishes eventually…

    however..the say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.This guy must idolise u…the fact that he even reads ur blog means alot…..SO,after u sue his clay a$$ and take over writin in a certain newspaper…i suggest we welcome him to blogring “thinker’s servant quarter’s room”

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/3081800 Deno

    Man it is AMAZING what you can miss from one week’s abscence form the kenyan blogosphere!!!!! I have learnt my lesson – kumbe things are MOTO MOTO.

    I think we all owe you M for your fearless writing hehe – and ofcourse with Ory’s brilliant advocacy via global voices- you have helped validate the growing eveolution of blogs in the context of Kenya.

    Our opinions are becoming stronger and stronger by the day!

  • http://www.clearyourskin.be nice skin

    I agree. Hey, you have a Cool site. I like the design a lot. thanks.