Live Aid? Please!
28
June
[EDIT]
The latest buzz over G8, Commissions For Africa, Live 8 and all the latest catch phrases leave me decidedly amused. I for one am deeply sceptical that all this fresh hubbub of the latest fashionable buzz words, taking over from “War On Terror”, “Globalization” and “Peace Accord” are nothing but unadulterated, politically correct, sanctimonious hot air.
I am frequently puzzled with references in the press to a mysterious “famous rock star” rejoicing under the name Bob Geldof, closely associated with this new set of buzz words. If he is so famous just how many of us would turn and point him out to our brethren if we saw him in the street. How is he famous? Who can spell Geldof? Quick, when did he last release a rock hit?
What’s his latest CD called? Name one song this illustrious rock star has done.
Bob is under the fond impression that if he organizes a concert in Scotland, manna, kebabs and fruit juice will descend from the heavens to fill the bellies of millions of starving Africans. Winged warriors will dispatch dictators and despots into the outer darkness where they can weep and gnash their gold teeth. Farmers will earn dollars from their produce rather than the cents they currently earn.
If a concert in Africa would have me sceptical, words cannot describe just how I fail to see how the remotest benefit a 1 million strong concert in Edinburgh will be derived by a poor fisherman in Lamu. I don’t see how one million partygoers will contribute to the filling of stomachs in Darfur, or a reduction of the gunfire. This concert, oddly enough, does not seem to have any African musicians performing aside from the good old token Yossou N’dour, something that will no doubt soon be hastily corrected and laughed off as a “technical oversight”.
Eager to chip into the latest mass conscience message are Hollywood’s biggest and brightest stars and starlets. Apparently the ilk of Brad Pitt, Angelina Jolie, George Clooney and their fellows leading ladies and gents were suddenly so overwhelmed by the plight of the poor that they actually wrote letters to the G8 nuclei. I was not party to the correspondence but I suspect most of it went like this:
Please please please reduce poverty in A free car Afrikka Africka Afrika
Yours,
[Star Name Here]
The Coca Cola company trademarked the distinctive shape of their bottle. So should Tony Blair with his toothy grin. I have no doubt that said grin would be produced even if a passing albatross deposited a considerable load of guano on his head. Realizing that his role of George’s unwitting puppy dog was costing him at Downing Street as well as Down His Street, he cottoned on to something that he felt sure would earn him marks far and wide.
And so the Commission For Africa© was born.
Its vision, mission and modus operandi are simplicity in itself — make poverty and bad governance in Africa disappear by making poverty and bad governance disappear. Some of the presidential members of his board, who will remain unnamed, arrived late having missed their flights from the Continent because of being held up to attend to the pressing business of jailing errant opposition members.
Of course the elections were held and good old Tony got in by the skin of his grinning teeth and now he is on more pressing matters like bans on fox hunting and how best to commemorate the Battle of Trafalgar.
It is laughable for anyone to take these latest initiatives with anything but amusement. The reality of the matter is that these latest buzzwords are a desperate attempt of a world that has grown decidedly weary of Iraq, Afghanistan, wars on terror and Middle East Peace Accords to find another avenue to massage its collective conscience and feel good about itself, basking in the warm glow associated with selfless charity.
Rosy pictures of children in Darfur gratefully accepting food from their benevolent benefactors sends little ecstatic shivers up and down suited forms. The thought of influencing millions of lives using their stardom leaves the constituents of the Hollywood constellation giddy with glee.
Personally I find it laughable watching a knighted man with a good dinner in his belly and the remnants of the said dinner at his elbow addressing the press from a plush, six star hotel in his passionate and very genuine belief that he can strike the blow that will end world poverty.
I find it even more ludicrous to see grinning Prime Ministers, treating us to displays of constellations of 76 assorted incisors, canines, molars, premolars and post molars, shaking hands before flashing bulbs while bemoaning the proliferation of small and large arms in Africa after just coming from superintending loading of consignments of machine pistols, rifles and land mines to Somalia, Sudan and Congo (via DHL of course).
Meaningless concerts and laughable commissions are not going to fight any poverty. Even dubiously benevolent concessions like debt cancellation are meaningless in themselves. It is utterly meaningless to cancel my debt if you do not allow me to earn money. Let us both compete fairly on the International market. Your farmers are already enjoying considerable technological advantages — they do not need subsidies. Don’t wax lyrical about debt relief if without avenues for me earning my own money I shall promptly be in debt again.
The quicker leaders of poor nations that appear begging in 6 door Mercedes limousines are thrown out smartly on their ears the sooner they will learn from the school of hard knocks that they have to live within their means. If they do not their populace should consign them to obscurity at the next elections. And if they have dipped into the till a few years stretching
out at a prison bunk ought to work wonders for the attitudes of those following in their footsteps.
So the concert will be held. Fun will be had. Alcohol will be consumed. People will do what they do on the Discovery channel. Millions will the raised. By the time the morning milk sounds in Irish doorways hangover revellers will have forgotten what the joyous rapture was in aid of. By the time the advertising companies, the equipment providers, the caterers, the security companies, the travel agencies, the hotels and the innumerable NGOs take their cut a few thousand pounds will be left that will be smugly handed over to Oxfam or other such agency, ostensibly to alleviate poverty and hunger in Africa. By the time administrative costs and taxes have been deducted, one medium sized MacDonald burger will be winging its determined was Africa-wise, and another Asia-wise to alleviate world hunger.
No, I am not holding my breath. The solution will not come from Live Aid or from G8. It will come from Africans who will finally refuse to accept the nonsense they are subjected to by their asinine leadership and throw the lot of the useless cretins out.
It will come from Africans who will put their skills and abilities to use for their countries.
It will come from Africans who will refuse to acknowledge the empty gestures from Europe and America, whose only concern is how best to plunder the continent of its resources and people without ruffling too many feathers and upsetting too many of their taxpayers.
It will not, repeat NOT come from Bob Geldof and Tony Blair or any other two faced, ostensibly benevolent big brothers who shed crocodile tears and conveniently ignore the fact that they spend as much on dog food than on their goodwill “aid”.
It will not come from Brad Pitt, George Clooney or indeed anyone attention hungry starlette whose only knowledge of Africa is that the people there speak a mysterious language called ‘African’, live on trees and swing from branch to branch clad in leopard skins while bellowing to each other.
More discussion of live8
The only people who can solve Africa’s problems are Africans.
Follow up: Get Real: Global Politics 101 & Live 8
BY THE WAY…
Anyone care to tell me how the proliferation of “Make Poverty History” arm bands, website banners, mugs, pantyhose etc. are meaningfully affecting the price of tomatoes, aside from giving the wearers a nice warm glow?
PIC OF THE DAY
Someone’s been eating my porridge!
President Mwai Kibaki suspiciously eyes Secretary General of the Asian and African Legal Consultative Organisation
Gwen Stefani - Hollaback Girl




1. Shiro
(130 Comments) | June 28th, 2005 at 10:44 am
Your are so right i have the same feelings about G8.
2. Anonymous
(No Comments) | June 28th, 2005 at 4:55 pm
uuuuwu! Clearly you don’t think much of Bob Geldof, Live 8 and Tony Blair’s commission!
Well said!
3. Anonymous
(No Comments) | June 28th, 2005 at 10:01 pm
I discovered this blog when BBC Online highlighted it. I’m really impressed with the quality of the writing and the keen observations that accompany them!
On Western Aid, we Africans need to understand (and the sooner the better) that the West largely operates on Machiavellian philosophies. Every move and opportunity is analyzed and calculated. They never do anything for nothing in return, even within their own families.
I had heard all this before in high school literature and fasihi akina Burdens, Kisiki etc and thought the authors were simply delusional. Only after living in the US for 4 years now am I beginning to see the reality.
Even the debt relief they are gloating over will leave us with bad credit ratings! So is poverty in Africa really the “White Man’s Burden”?
M, keep up the good work!
4. D
(No Comments) | June 29th, 2005 at 11:16 am
Well said! Until Africans break off from their abusers( both european and African leaders who look out for their own and european interests) we will still be asking ‘Massa’ to gives a little more food/aid/etc.
Yaani tangu Europeans ‘discovered’ Africa we have been eating shit and I am always shocked when I hear Africans who still think the solution lies with the same governments and systems that messed you up in the first place.
Want to bet Mr Geldof will saving Africa 20 years from now?!
I can see it now, Save Africa 2024!
To show how much they think of Africa, they forgot to invite them to the party! Honestly when will the African learn. 200 years of being played like a fool is not enough?
BTW there is an interesting documentary out there that has just been released that touches on this stuff. GOOGLE ‘500 years later’.
To Africans, get it together, you are the only ones who will solve your problems not some over fed, western celeberity
Keep the good thinker
5. kari
(No Comments) | June 29th, 2005 at 12:03 pm
u are so on point!! yani uv captured a thought av had for a while..like u jua this ‘make poverty history’ armbands that have came along?i dont have anything against them per se,but how much of that money that has been raised by those armbands has been used to help the starving farmer in somalia????its just a fashion item at the end of the day…we need to do things that make sense and not just coz it looks/sounds gud…
6. Prousette
(143 Comments) | June 29th, 2005 at 12:53 pm
Well said;
Same goes for those charitable organizations who wait for Xmas to dish out sweets to children who have been starving the whole year, how does that help their lives and Ohh… the media has to be very prominently present.
I noticed that the Live8 idea was to CREATE awareness. Yaani these idiots do not know there’s a situation in Darfur after all these media stories the best way would have been give a few geougraphy lessons or two a little history then economics.
As for our leaders/beggars I have no words.
7. Anonymous
(No Comments) | June 29th, 2005 at 3:37 pm
Excellent read, Thinker’s in top-top form as usual. The Live8 shenainigans are just another way of making the white West feel superior. They don’t recognise the role of pan-African activism (It’s as if we’re all waiting for the West to come and save us!) and I bet that 20years from now, when Africa has rejuvenated itself (and it will) Geldof & co will claim responsibility for its rejuvenation. It’s just another insult at Africans.
8. baz
(No Comments) | June 29th, 2005 at 9:03 pm
Guys, this is supposed to be a controversial issue, so how come everyone seems to be on the same side? Okay, let me speak for the bad guy: It would be nice if Sir Bob was promoting some idea of how to eradicate poverty, instead of just reiterating the obvious fact that it ought to be eradicated; it would be cool if his goal was more than the nebulous and vague “raising awareness”. And it is stupid to have 50 Cent on the bill and not have Talib Kweli or at least Chuck D, but though his efforts are skating quite close to silliness, at least he is doing something, no matter how misguided it may seem.
He is doing something, not just saying “What a shame” then leaping into his limo to head for the greens. At least he has dedicated effort, time and resources to this.
That is more than can be said for many of us right here in Africa, who could chose between DSTv and, I don’t know, a monthly donation to a clinic in the village, but never even think about it. No Prado-driving, Nokia-toting, two-storey-Muthaiga-house-living, UK-degree-having African should rant against Live 8 on the net without that: doing “something” whatever it is.
Okay, maybe you may suspect his motives. You could say he is just conning us for publicity. Even if that is the case, that much-touted “awareness” HAS been raised and African poverty is on the agenda now. And though this is not the same as a warm meal in every manyatta, it is better than being completely ignored.
Finally, M, you have great taste in music. I know, because so have I.
9. KymmBr.
(No Comments) | June 29th, 2005 at 10:19 pm
Need i say more? Only Africans can remove themselves form their present predicament. ONLY THEM!! to expect outsiders who donn really know what level of poverty africans currently face to help them is laughable. Yes. look wide but never be a beggar.
we can’t wait for the manna to fall fron heaven while we donn even know heaven from hell. What can we trust?
10. WM
(38 Comments) | June 30th, 2005 at 1:41 am
You know, I think I have a somewhat supernatural relationship with blogging. Mara people just sign on as WM and it leads to my link, and mara I write a lengthy think piece on the issues M raised and it has disappeared. Wassup with that. So, okay, you may get to read this twice, but it bears repeating so I don’t feel too bad (sorry for blogging on your blog, thinker, and your thinking is like mainlining mind vitamins as usual). There is NO DEBT. Again, THERE IS NO DEBT. Africa owes the West NOTHING. NOTHING. On the balance owed to us, however, (does anyone have a calculator handy)we have a good five hundred years or resource and personnel theft, deliberate underdevelopment and intereference in our politics (Lumumba anyone?) continuing depredations and destruction (Shell in Nigeria, anyone?) and theft theft theft. Look, if somebody mugs you, takes your wallet and your car, are you really going to be grateful ati because they gave you busfare home. I don’t understand why we haven’t understood that we are being bamboozled into thinking INSIDE this very coercively-enforced box, where up is down, black is white, and we owe the West money instead of the other way around. BTW, can someone calculate from around 200 to 500 years cumulative interest? It seems to me unethical even to let them frame the TERMS and the concepts of the debate–our negotiating room is about as much as you get if you are the last passenger in a very crowded lift. So now I’ve nyira-ed, I’ve clicked my tongue in annoyance, I’ve done that sucking teeth thing that West Africans are good at, and I am generally producing physical expressions of utmost contempt for bloody G8 concerts, musicians, and fashion taste. Now I think I’ll go and get really pissed off about something.
11. Anonymous
(No Comments) | June 30th, 2005 at 2:09 am
it’s great to rant and rave about africa for africans. so where do we go from here? now that we all agree africa for africans what’s the plan of action????? do we reverse brain drain such that all our professionals (and non-professionals) return home kujenga nchi? these ideas, critiques and remarks are thoughtful but they should be accompanied by some kind of action on our part…..wherever we may be!
12. D
(No Comments) | June 30th, 2005 at 2:13 am
@ Baz.
if Awareness is what is being created, then the man is way behind. Is there anyone in the world who does not know that there is poverty in Africa and most of it is created by artificial circumstances( greedy African elites and Europeans)?
I know of Africans/kenyans ( with and without UK degrees) who have given of there time and still do but do so without seeking publicity. I know of Doctors offering free medical care/check ups to AIDS patients from the slums of Nairobi and ask for nothing in return and with zero funding from ‘donors’( and they don’t want it either, it comes with too many conditions like using specific donor funded drugs,etc). If any of those doctors was a European, they would have a book and movie deal by now.
Many Africans are sacrificing alot, but as Geldof said when asked about why there are few African musicians on the bill, ‘who knows them’( I heard it as ‘who gives a shit’).
Awareness indeed.
The only people who can save Africa are the Africans, there is no society in the world that has been saved by outsiders. Not a single one.
13. WM
(38 Comments) | June 30th, 2005 at 2:19 am
Me again M,
(Sorry, this will be a bit obscure to everybody else…)
As a matter of fact, NO, I can’t spell sxcizo, schozo, sciso, ah, the thing where your head is like a crowded matatu!
14. M
(No Comments) | June 30th, 2005 at 9:41 am
@baz - Bob Geldof is doing nothing but riding a very comfortable gravy train that fills his belly with good food and his pockets with the odd coin, plus he gets to travel and see the world. He is on to a good deal, and I admire his ingenuity, in that he has found a way to make a living when his flagging career gave up the ghost.
Personally i’m not impressed with his benevolent act. He has been doing the same thing since 1985, a good 20 years ago so you’ll excuse me if I fail to go giddy with admiration and gratitude for the dude. There’s nothing new that he has raised that has not already been in the public domain! From time immemorial people have known that Africa has lots of problems. A concert will have about as much effect as a raindrop in the ocean.
I don’t drive a prado, and I don’t have a two storey Muthaiga house and I don’t have a UK degree. However you do not know what I do to help, and this is not the forum for me to say. However let me say this: even if I was doing nothing at all what I have written here is doing plenty to pull the wool from over the eyes of the millions of people who are hoodwinked by the day that Live 8 and G8 will ever solve anything. Knowledge, my friend, is power.
I have no apologies to make over what I have written. As long as one mind has seen the light and realized that the solution lies from within then I have done my part.
@WM - taken words right out of my mouth! Who owes who?? BTW can you spell Multiple Personality Disorder?
15. Anonymous
(No Comments) | June 30th, 2005 at 2:51 pm
To D and M,
I can’t log in now, but this is Baz.
Awareness is not manna, but it’s better than nothing.
I, too, am inclined to think that Old Sir Bob is just using Africa to get some of that spotlight back, considering that he hasn’t had a hit in decades. Or, at least, because I try to give everyone the benefit of the doubt, he is a simpleminded hippie who thinks shouting about it will make poverty dissapear. But I know Live 8 WILL NOT save Africa.
But at least give him this: his motives have not affected the result of his act. Things have been stirred up. Now Andy Kershaw is complainig, and the BBC has to run a story about Geldof’s latest plot and the controversy it’s causing. The complacent, ignorant listeners worldwide are asking, “What’s all this Live 8 malarkey about?” And the Beeb has to bring someone on who will give a comprehensive and detailed picture of the problems we face. Awareness raised. Good thing.
Just like M’s article. Talk, facts, insight. People know more and understand better.
I am not saying that the poor will be fed by awareness, but I wouldn’t want to die in the dark, with no one knowing about it. Some one has to feel sorry, someone has to feel guilty. If some silly old man’s vain shenanigans are going to remind the world of the state of affairs, I won’t stand in his way.
GOOD SAMARITANS
D, you mentioned all those golden-hearted doctors and health volunteers who ask for no payment or recognition for their acts. Of course I commend and admire them.
I know a few people like that too. They tend to be modest, but I keep telling them they are not helping their cause by hiding their light.
Let others know that something is being done, let others know HOW something can be done; that way more people can be inspired to join in.
BTW, I hope you did not misunderstand my prado-muthaiga-M.A. Leeds Uni comment. I wasn’t speaking of anyone specific, just trying to say most of the few privileged Africans tend to soapbox a whole lot more than they act.
16. Wangari
(10 Comments) | June 30th, 2005 at 3:45 pm
I am not an expert in this but here is my novice opinion;
on the one hand;
Geldof, Bono, Chris Martin and all those other celebrities can go about “Making Poverty History” until the cows home but unless we Africans do something about our countries, nothing is going to change.
Mugabe will still be burning down people’s houses because he thinks its good sport, our politicians will still continue to amass as much wealth as their bulging tummies can hold and Darfur will continue to be lighted up by gun-blast fireworks.
so YES!!! I agree, only African’s can help Africans and concerts in Cornwall will not change anything.
on the other hand;
I think its admirable that the said celebrities are doing something. They could soo easily be spending their time snorting cocaine or sunning themselves around various holiday spots but they have decided to get off their behinds and do something for people that they couldnt give a monkeys about and will probably never get to see.
Their intentions might be to make them feel powerful, to get public endorsements (read more fans buying their cd’s), or even land various advertising contracts but it is the thought that counts and in this case it is a good thought. I think that some good might come out of it.
Here is a likely scenario;
Some teenager from Glamorgan walking around a supermarket with a wristful of the MPH armbands, still dazed from seeing Bono belt out “Where the Streets Have no Name” notices on the shelf a Fairtrade pack of tea. The claim on the pack is that some of the money that he spends on this pack will go back to the grower in Kenya so he coughs up the extra pence required for this pack and buys it. In actual fact (and I know this because I am involved in fairtrade as far as tea is concerned) that money DOES find its way back to the grower in Kenya. Specifically to Kiegoi factory in Meru as they are the only fairtrade registered factory in Kenya. I was there last year and the money they have received so far has been spent building a clinic and a nursery school and they were starting on the roads up to the factory. So, the teenager up in Scotland has made a change despite only doing it because Bono said so..
So, while the motives behind these concerts may not be entirely pure, there is some good there and we should appreciate this and let it rekindle the fire we have to each in our own way make poverty history at home.
17. M
(No Comments) | June 30th, 2005 at 5:15 pm
@ baz — my point is that everyone and their uncle is fully aware that Africa is festooned with problems. Bob is just a savvy dude who has spotted the gravy train well in advance. Awareness is there, and lots of it.
18. Ina
(No Comments) | June 30th, 2005 at 5:56 pm
Hmm
Unfortunately Im not going despite it all however I do think the concert will be very enjoyable…hey how did you know I was on your blog?
19. M
(No Comments) | June 30th, 2005 at 6:15 pm
@ Ina - I have no doubt whatsoever it will be an enjoyable concert. I however think that in terms of poverty alleviation it will be about as useful as a chocolate teapot.
As for knowing how you were by — I have an army of gremlins in my employ {Sinister laugh here}
20. Anonymous
(No Comments) | June 30th, 2005 at 6:37 pm
@wangari, i think it may be erroneous to lump geldof with Bono and Chris Martin. Their approaches are quite different. Bono and Chris Martin have a whole other ethos (Debt cancellation and Fair trade respectively) Those 2 chaps are cool in my book because they are championing enabling solutions. Geldof?? dunno.
21. Imnakoya
(No Comments) | June 30th, 2005 at 8:06 pm
The punch line in your post is this, and it is really positive:
It will come from Africans who will put their skills and abilities to use for their countries.
It will come from Africans who will refuse to acknowledge the empty gestures from Europe and America, whose only concern is how best to plunder the continent of its resources and people without ruffling too many feathers and upsetting too many of their taxpayers.
It will not, repeat NOT come from Bob Geldof and Tony Blair or any other two faced, ostensibly benevolent big brothers who shed crocodile tears and conveniently ignore the fact that they spend as much on dog food than on their goodwill “aid”…
Why not focus on this and identify ways this can be realized? Negative energy does not good, and perhaps the meagre ounce of postivity about this concert can be harnessed and propagated into something of greater positivity?
22. baz
(No Comments) | June 30th, 2005 at 8:20 pm
“You know what the tragic thing is? That I don’t care anymore. Really, I used to, but then it seemed nothing was changing. It just seemed to be getting worse and worse. And, I’m only one guy, you know, I can’t handle all this. So I quit. I quit. It was either that or they take me down with them.”
I’m paraphrasing of course. I think the guy’s name is Paul Jameson, though.
23. Emeka Okafor
(No Comments) | June 30th, 2005 at 10:31 pm
Take a look at
Rock Star Economics by Franklin Cudjoe
24. Anonymous
(No Comments) | July 1st, 2005 at 3:11 am
Oh give me a break… you sanctimonious complainers… at least Bob Geldof is doing something… Kenya’s MP’s (vultures, hyenas, fat cats & rats - apologies to the animals themselves) are SCREWING Kenyans left, right & in the ass…
Sure Mbeki fired zuma but how many more corrupt characters in his government?
Prez for life Museveni - Why attack Geldof when Muze Muse plans to die in office! Of course, his brother (salim swaleh or something like that) is buying used helicopters for BILLIONS (of USHS)…
Don’t forget Kenya’s Navy buying a Shs 4B warship/destroyer!!!
Again… don’t fret about Geldof… do something about the CROOKS in your midst!
25. Michael Michalko
(No Comments) | July 1st, 2005 at 5:12 am
Well said !
26. M
(No Comments) | July 1st, 2005 at 9:21 am
@Anonymous - you’re right, and I agree with you but you are somewhat off tangent.
Again I repeat - Bob Geldof is not doing anything. Everyone and their uncle is aware of Africa’s problems. Those concerts are just that — concerts.
I have already acknowledged that are utter wastrels among us that we need to get rid of.
27. M
(No Comments) | July 1st, 2005 at 9:45 am
By the way, odd that the extremely vocal Kenyan Blogosphere is rather silent on this … hello!!! Where are you hiding?
28. D
(No Comments) | July 1st, 2005 at 10:44 am
@ Wangari, @ Baz and @ Anonymous.
Its good that fair trade and all that is working out. But my question is, when are Africans going to take charge of their own desitinies, when are we going to clean up our houses before we start asking for handouts?
our problems lie very close to home and we see them driving into the many African cities in state of the art benzs and 4wd most obtained from in stolen ‘AID’/or tax payers money( the political class). Geldof has an approach but like Jeffery sachs, they chose to ignore the most potent thing, African Elites( and a sprinkling of European MNC) are responsible for the poverty and misery. IMHO the only ways this situation can be effectively tackled, are
1: Africans! get it together and run a tighter ship
2:Stop looking to external saviours
3: Get rid of your useless leadership ( by which ever means possible).
4:give up the begging culture.
29. Anne
(No Comments) | July 1st, 2005 at 1:17 pm
As a keen follower of the Kenyan Blogosphere, I can answer your query “odd that the extremely vocal Kenyan Blogosphere is rather silent on this … hello!!! Where are you hiding?”
I have also wondered how come your posts, excellent as they are, don’t raise as many comments as other, to be frank, mediocre postings, a question I am sure which triggered you to write Quality Control.
Like Michael Joseph said, our blog readers and writers are peculiar. It seems to be largely driven by patronage and quid pro quo — I’ll comment on your blog if you comment on mine, which is so sad it’s almost funny.
You, my friend, are at a handicap because you do not spend hours and hours trawling the 80 odd blogs on the Kenyan Blogosphere to stuff them with mundane comments.
You are also further handicapped by not belonging to certain mysterious blog ‘families’ and therefore filling reams and reams of blogspace with pointless white noise.
And you are further handicapped by your versatility — your blog really cannot be categorized into one category or another because you cut across religion, politics, social commentary, world affairs, poetry … someone who gets excited by a post headed “This is not a post” will in all likelihood flounder at the depths here.
Yours is one of the few blogs where people post genuinely in reaction to what you have said and not some funny sense of obligation from comments you have left elsewhere.
I hope this keeps up. It’s satisfying to read reactions to your posts and not pointless greetings and invitations
You my friend have a supreme gift. Just keep doing what you are doing. Prophets are always rejected in their home towns. But I can tell you that you command a quite significant following over here. Keep the faith
Anne
P.S. I’ve sent you an email. I hope I got your address right?
30. Anonymous
(No Comments) | July 1st, 2005 at 7:11 pm
Hi,
What the west has done to us has basically been a prolonged series of kicks - below the belt, above the knee, in the middle!!
My take is that we already have the lessons from the past and hopes for our future. Lets work on our todays. What are you doing today to assist Africa?
31. Anonymous
(No Comments) | July 1st, 2005 at 9:20 pm
@anne
Sanctimonious today huh arent you? Before you start wailing about how much back scratching is going on in the blogosphere, go get a back scratch from a tree. You sound like a bureaucrat badly in need of a life. If you have a problem with other people’s comments on OTHER people’s blogs, why dont you get a blog and chart the ‘mundane’ comments as you so keenly follow the goings on in the kenyan blogosphere. If someone has a blog family, what is it to you? Its THEIR blog! Uchocheo is what you are doing and most people in the kenyan blogosphere know better than to buy into your B.S. If you want to give props just so without slipping into an indictment of the blogosphere. Err an you appear to be quite mediocre yourself, i happened to like quality control! Now back to regular M programming…
32. Binti
(No Comments) | July 2nd, 2005 at 6:52 pm
Clearly said let Africans save themselves and we can only do so by doing away with these greedy leaders…..
33. Echo Mouse
(No Comments) | July 3rd, 2005 at 1:10 am
Well I think it’s all been discussed here. Great to see a perspective from the source.
I’ve tried to highlight some issues on my blog with respect to this Live8 thing. In the end, my personal opinion is that awareness is always needed because people forget when they’re not reminded. Trade is needed to help Africa stand on it’s own. Government overhaul is dearly needed but that’s something only you and your fellow citizens can accomplish. And as for doubling aid - I am not convinced that is required. Aid is still needed, yes, but throwing massive amounts of money at Africa and hoping that will magically fix everything is naive at best.
Great blog. I’ll link you so I can keep up with this.
34. Dan100
(No Comments) | July 3rd, 2005 at 4:17 am
The G8 control world trade. Their policies control the markets which set the prices of tomatoes on markets in Africa. Until they change their trade policies, third world farmers will not get a fair deal.
The G8 leaders aren’t going to bother doing anything until they believe that the voters who put them in power just might not vote for them again, unless they doing something about this. Organising concerts attended by millions is a fairly good way to bring that kind pressure to bear
.
And aid is still needed. HIV/AIDs drugs don’t pay for themselves. Basic sanitations and water purification doesn’t come out of thin air. Food relief in the event of disasters doesn’t happen by itself.
35. Anonymous
(No Comments) | July 3rd, 2005 at 3:40 pm
We can sit on our lazy bums and pick fault with those who try to do something.However minimaal and whatever their motivation atleast they are trying while lazy africans can only point fingers.When did i see or hear of an african ideaa like this..even if it achieved nothing.If one hungry child will be fed because BoB Geldorf wanted fame so be it….
36. M
(No Comments) | July 3rd, 2005 at 4:07 pm
@dan - i have not said that aid is bad — however, there is no point in giving aid if within no time we will be right back where we started and be holding a Live 9. I’ll write a comprehensive blog with all my reactions to this post and a healthy debate can arise from there
@anonymous - calling me lazy, and such flattering comments will get you nowhere. You have no idea what it is i do to help out my contrymen, and therefore you are in no position to offer condescending diatribes. Kindly read my post and respond to it in its entirety and not to selected lines
37. Kenyan Pundit
(18 Comments) | July 3rd, 2005 at 4:40 pm
Hey M, I’m late to the party…all I wanted to say was that all its misdirection etc. aside, at the very least, Live 8 has produced some of the most cogent discussion on Africa that I’ve ever seen and has demonstrated the power of technology (blogs, live streaming, technorati, et al) to connect the dots and bring a wide range of voices to the table.
38. Anonymous
(No Comments) | July 3rd, 2005 at 6:01 pm
The only ones who can solve Africa’s problems are Africans? How are they doing so far?
39. coffay
(No Comments) | July 4th, 2005 at 3:49 am
What you said was right to some point, but do you really think Africans can save Africa? Seriously?
What have they done so far?
I have lived in Africa my whole life (well, almost, my whole life take 7 months) and where my people would NEVER be able to over throw the dictaor themselves. Inseted they stand watching helplessly as their homes are demolished by the government in an effort to “clean up”. The people i know are quite and peaceful and they just seem to accept whats happening and say “change will come soon”. They can’t do anything about it simply because they dont want to die, or be tortured, or whatever. Thabo Mbeki chose “quiet diplomacy” - that, he thinks will help the situation, has it worked so far?
um…. NO!
How much money goes into setting up a huge concert anyway, enough to buy food aid for lots of starving people, i think. Even if they tried to give aid to the countries, who do the give it to? The governments? I hope not!!!
40. M
(No Comments) | July 4th, 2005 at 11:31 am
@anonymous — some progress is being made. Peace deals of sorts has been brokered by Africans to sort out the problems in Sudan, Somali and Congo. The AU is starting to get its act together.
Some progress is being made
@coffay - Thabo Mbeki’s reluctance to ruffle feathers when it comes to Mugabe is taking him dangerously close to being a coward
41. baz
(No Comments) | July 4th, 2005 at 11:45 am
M, every one is aware? Not as much before as they are now.
It is easy to abstract other people’s misery and detach ourselves from it. Here in Yuppie Africa we do it as much as Gen-x-ers in Idaho, so though we know there is such a thing as poverty, we don’t feel moved to act. Until they do that finger-snapping every three seconds thing advert they showed during the concert.
Did you guys watch the thing? I was earlier inclined to see Sir Bob as a slightly batty but generally kind-hearted old hippie who’s heart is in a righter place than his grip on reality, but now that Live 8 has taken place, I have to tip my hat.
I walk through a little slum to get to my home every day, but I didn’t know as much about the scale and degrees of African poverty as I do now after the commetary, advocacy and punditry that has surrounded the concert. If I was thousands of Italian rock fans, you bet I would be pressurising my prime minister to style up about Africa!
42. M
(No Comments) | July 4th, 2005 at 11:57 am
@ baz - pressure you say? The sad thing is that politics is not that simple. Just read my latest post to see what i mean.
43. MMK
(No Comments) | July 4th, 2005 at 2:42 pm
This is a great post and reflects my feelings and thoughts to the letter. I want to take issue with anonymous who seems to be of the impression that Africans who do not apreciate the Geldof’s of the world are giving a free pass to the Mugabes. Nothing could be further from the truth. In fact, aid and charity have been intimately connected to dictatorship in Africa. Most governments face the West more than they do their own people because they know there is a ready source of funds to be gained based on the misery of their people. The incentives are perverse. It is only by rejecting the centrality of Western charity to our lives that we shall begin to deal with our problems on the basis that no one is going to save us except ourselves.
And on this matter of being saved. Africa has been a perpetual charity project for the west for the last few hundred years. Even during the height of slavery and colonialism, the mission was always represented as one of mercy and salvation. When King Leopold II of Belgium did away with ten million Congolese, effectively halving the country’s population, between 1880 and 1920, he was doing so in the name of saving a benighted people. How ironic that the band wagon rolls on, how ironic and disgusting that Africa’s leaders and NGO junkies still turn to the very Belgium, Britain, France etc to save us. How many lessons must we learn before it finally dawns on us that there is no-one looking out for you?
44. Stefan
(No Comments) | July 4th, 2005 at 5:06 pm
I don’t know how many people followed the Africa Calling event at the Eden Project in Cornwall, England, which, in my opinion, was a much better representation of what Africa is. Africa is not all bad, it has a lot of talent that, when given the right outlet, can be exceptionally positive.
Look at the incredible work that Youssou N’Dour has done in his home country, look how Angelique Kidjo has raised awareness, people who have been able to make so much of their talents. Youssou N’Dour made it clear that opening markets to the African people for their wares is more important than just throwing money at the problem.
Geldof may have no ulterior motive, but you don’t get the point if you have a bunch of self-congratulatory rockers on a stage somewhere, while they have never been to some of the most deprived areas in Africa, and understood what the root of the problem is.
45. Afromusing
(28 Comments) | July 4th, 2005 at 6:51 pm
hear hear M and MMK.
46. Anonymous
(No Comments) | July 4th, 2005 at 10:57 pm
I quite agree Live 8 etc will do nothing to help…and quite frankly I think its a total waste handing more money to Africa…
Dont go blaming the white man and the west tho for all your problems…the black men who raped and pillaged their own lands to sell to the white man are equally to blame…if it wasnt for the west also do you really think Africa on its own could capitalise on its resources? You would still be fighting amongst yourselves…and still blaming the west and the evil white man…
47. Anonymous
(No Comments) | July 5th, 2005 at 12:48 am
@Baz
I back your comments man. Its far easier to pull down than to put up.
@M
What’s your solution, if you want African nations to rise up tell us HOW! What do you say to oppression and internal corruption? HOW can the trampled even start to stand let alone fight. Come on - if you’re willing to criticise, create some solutions. Do I agree with some of your comments yes, do I agree with some of Baz’s yes. But jeepers can we roll with some solutions not character assasinations.
48. Anonymous
(No Comments) | July 5th, 2005 at 2:11 am
The western europeans got aid after world war two.(Marshal plan)they used it in a good way and now they dont have to beg.We can do it too.The argument that without aid africans wil wake up and help themselves might be true but after 50 years of starvation and decimation.Its like saying leave your changaa addicted brother to his vices and one day he’ll know the way to rehab..and watch his hungry children whet their lips when you eat!!!!
49. Anonymous
(No Comments) | July 5th, 2005 at 2:37 am
hmm.. interesting comments.. but charachterising ‘the west’ like that falls into the same trap as the ‘africa’ categorisation.. its a blanket statement..
most people who live in the west are working class and poor (and white, thats something that many black middle class intellectuals in america prefer to ignore)..
so as a poor white person who lives in a council house i’d have to say i ‘owe you jack shit mate’..
to say that shell is representitive of the majority of people is simplistic to say the least..
and another thing.. many slaves were sold out by their own chiefs who did deals with the slave traders (still a point of contention to this day btw)
so lets make a distinction..the common man in the west is not africas enemy.. saying that i think patronising middle class white people don’t help either.. we have them here.. they’re called social workers
50. Anonymous
(No Comments) | July 5th, 2005 at 2:57 am
hmm .. more interesting comments..slightly misleading..
please note that the Marshall plan didn’t involve the Uk to the same extent as Germany and Japan (kind of ironic if you think about it) .. it took GB plc until 1974 to pay the US back for its ‘aid’ in WW2.. plus property such as Bermuda, radar, jet engine nuclear weapons and computer technology and access to many British markets.. so the US was paid.. in full.. as much as ‘hollywood’ would have you believe it was all done on a gesture of goodwill.. think again.. the US made a profit on WW2.. the only country to do so.. one of the blogs here mentions Machiavellian tendencies.. so i thought i’d pass this on for youto think about.. even though it is slightly OT
regards Q
51. M
(No Comments) | July 5th, 2005 at 9:57 am
Man, i wish people would use names instead of this anonymous thing so I can respond to each!
#1 Stop quoting isolated lines of my sentiments. Again, I have acknowledged that Africans are also responsible for their problems in terms of inept governments and apathetic voters
#2 I have already outlined some of the things that can be done ( a list that is by no means exhaustive. I’ll probably blog about it in a bit)
#3 At no time have i said anyone owes me anything!
52. M
(No Comments) | July 5th, 2005 at 11:57 am
And as to whether Africa can harness her own resources — that chap who said Africa can’t — are you kidding me??
HECK yeah!
53. Anonymous
(No Comments) | July 5th, 2005 at 12:00 pm
Please see our comments from Johannesburg http://www.represent.co.za
54. Stefan
(No Comments) | July 5th, 2005 at 1:56 pm
This morning’s newspapers in the UK declared that the artists who had performed at the Hyde Park concert (and elsewhere), had seen a 1000% upswing (yes, one thousand percent) in album sales following Live 8. There are calls that those artists enjoying this surge in sales should pledge to give this same surge in profit to Live 8. Sounds fair enough to me.
55. M
(No Comments) | July 5th, 2005 at 2:43 pm
@ Stefan - Bob Geldof has taught well — popular causes can keep you in the limelight AND line your pockets!
56. Stefan
(No Comments) | July 5th, 2005 at 3:16 pm
M, quite, quite… And THAT is what is the most patronising of it all.
57. Anonymous
(No Comments) | July 5th, 2005 at 4:20 pm
Hi M
Interesting stuff, in the UK it’s frankly difficult to hear what Africans think about all this. I have heard echoes of what you’re saying here but mainly from people using it as an excuse not to do anything.
What I want to ask you is this: Taking on board what you have said about the uselessness of Live 8, what would you have us (ie. British / people of ‘Developed’ countries) do? Personally, along with many other British people, I feel a lot of guilt over the way Africa has historically been treated by our countries. I am quite happy to take action, but am now being told that giving money does not help, protesting does not help, writing letters does not help… surely there’s SOMETHING left for us to do?
Peregrin
58. M
(No Comments) | July 5th, 2005 at 4:42 pm
@ Peregrin - about protesting — it’s not strictly true that protesting does nothing. Protesting is viable insofar as granting you what you want will not precipitate the powers that be in an unwanted situation. Look at America and the Global Warming thing. You can protest until you are blue in the face — Bush will not nuke his own industries.
That said and done there are plenty of things you can do
1) Visit Africa. Contrary to popular belief, not all of it is at war. Not all of it is unpaved. Not all of it is peppered with mud huts. There are beaches and scuba diving and curios and friendly people and game drives. I can personally vouch for Kenya’s and Uganda’s beauty. You WILL have a lovely time.
Visit Africa on your next holiday and bring your family. Discover for yourself the other side of the coin and have the additional benefit of creating much needed jobs. Tourism is a significant industry in Kenya
2) If you are in a position to volunteer your services, do so! There are parts of Africa badly in need of doctors, teachers, etc.
3) Acquaint yourself with FairTrade branded products.
4) Blanket Aid as far as I’m concerned never gets to those who need it. It is sheer folly giving some of these governments what is effectively a blank cheque.
If you can support a hospital or a school or a children’s home run by one of the numerous foundations with projects here you have more guarantee that your donation won’t end up in some fat cat’s Swiss bank account.
59. Neil
(No Comments) | July 5th, 2005 at 7:39 pm
The well-intentioned rock stars (and Bob Geldof is one over here, I’m afraid…) and happy crowds are about to be BETRAYED.
Here is an article detailing the real agenda of the G8 summit i.e. opening up Africa to exploitation by global monsternationals. Please take a couple of minutes to read it. It’s completely sourced.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/Columnists/Column/0,5673,1521411,00.html
60. Philip W
(No Comments) | July 5th, 2005 at 11:42 pm
BBC Online pointed me this way, and I’m glad I found your blog. Great to see an African perspective on all of this.
To be honest, I wasn’t too hopeful that Live 8 would accomplish real change for Africa - as you say, Africa’s problems need African solutions, and the best thing we could do in the west is to level the Trade playing field so Africans can compete and generate wealth.
Though I also feel you may have unjustly written off the genuine feelings of many in the west who do want to help. We might be misguided in our ways of going about it (maybe like thinking rock music can save Africa!) but for a lot of people it is important to feel like they are doing something meaningful. If you ask me, they’re looking in the wrong starting place, but the goodwill is there.
61. Anonymous
(No Comments) | July 7th, 2005 at 7:58 am
First of all I just wanted to say that i disagree with the majority of what you have commented upon. If you think for a minute that everyone already knows about the poverty that goes on in Africa and all around the world you are wrong, because there are so many people who may think they know but they have no idea. When these people begin to be well informed on the real issues in Africa they are stunned. The facts are astonishing to people that so many die a day, go without food, or do not have any housing over their heads. I’ve seen poverty not in Africa but in China and I want you to know that anything and I mean anything that can be done to help these people should be done. I do not think it is fair of you to say anything about Bob Geldof who by the way was a famous rocker from a long time ago and if many people our own age ask people from our parents generations they do know who he is. I believe it was he who put on the last concert that began to make some change in the hearts of polital leaders to begin cancelling debt and giving aid to Africa and though it has not made a durastic difference there it is better than sitting on our butts watching poor people starve to death on commercials and changing the channel because they could care less. I went to the live 8 concert in Philadelphia and I’ll have you know that though I’m sure there were many people there to just listen to the music they do have two ears to listen to what was being said about Africa. I do not know that this concert and those that went on around the world will have any impact on the decisions made by the world leaders at the G8 summit but at least someone tried. On another note I don’t think its fair for you or someone else in your comments to talk about the money being spent on the concert and how the artists sales have all gone up, which obviously I’m sure they have. People did make money off of this concert but I believe that these actors, actresses, singers and whomever else were out to raise a voice and make a difference. I believe in the saying that “we are the change we want to see in the world.” On another note I have had many conversations with people about President Bush. I am not a fan of him at all, and I think that it is very disturbing that we can sit and criticize the money people spent on the concerts but no one looks at all the money being spent in Iraq on a cause that is far and wide not close to as important and people dying everyday. We all know for a fact that if the number of people that died in one day in Africa happened here in America President Bush would be all over it, getting the problem solved. But when it comes to truely helping others, he would rather spend a couple billion and kill some more Iraqi people. I don’t think it is fair to say that Africans need to be the change and stand up for themselves, and I think that that was something that was very easy for you to say. I’m sure if you tried stepping into their shoes for one day, that thought would never cross your mind for fear of being killed, beaten or whatever other punishement they may make you endure. I just think that it is very easy for people to criticize the rich and famous people and make stabs at them, or the people who simply wear the white one campaign bracelets but at least they are attempting to make a change in the world whether it will come about or not. What you say just disturbs me.
62. M
(No Comments) | July 9th, 2005 at 1:48 pm
@ Anonymous — for some reason you have arrived at the erroneous conclusion that I am not African. I can do a lot more than walk in ‘their’ shoes for a day. I do it every day and have been doing it all my life for the excellent reason that i AM African
63. Claire
(No Comments) | July 11th, 2005 at 6:49 am
I like what you wrote, but i tend to think that the solution do not come from a continent or a population it is a Global solution, an international solution
64. ostara
(No Comments) | July 12th, 2005 at 3:00 pm
My problem with live 8 and Geldof in particular is that he is actually institutionalising protest, making it part of the establishment which of course neuters it and renders it impotent. Geldof called anarchists who rioted at Edinburgh losers. Why are they losers? Because they dont dance to Geldofs tune? Live 8 will do nothing to solve poverty in Africa. If it did it would have succeeded after Live Aid 20 years ago. Sucking up to international terrorists such as Bush and Blair will not change the world. At the same time Live 8 finished, Bono was in a Dublin court spending hundreds of thousands to get his hat back from a stylist he says stole it. Why? Because if there is money to be made out of U2, he is going to make it. That is greed and self absorption on a bloated and egotistical scale that defies belief. Live 8 and its precedents and antecedents are a big con. Makes people feel better even though they have done nothing, and leaves real activists totally frustrated because it is impossible to mobilise people who think the revolution has been won!
65. Curious
(6 Comments) | August 15th, 2005 at 5:36 pm
Now, now, your comments about Bob Geldof are not fair. In fact, in the west, too many would like to “stuff” Africa - to quote a piece from the Financial Times that still rings in my head.
I appreciate the point about the lack of eventual impact of band aid on the price of tomatoes, etc, but one should not belittle the effort of others.
Bob Geldof, I feel, may as well be an honorary African (not as like the post-colonial offspring but as the indigenous Africans). He has advocated for the abolition of the debt burden and the elimination of unethical trade policies. Both these issues are hard to approach without the clout of a PhD in development economics but he [Bob] has tried and done well, even more so because he is a rocker and we all know the associated stereotypes (as like those evidenced in your article).
Please read the article titled “suffering developing countries” to see that there are two side to every equation, i.e.: a causation and a result.
I submit to you that as in the west, there are Africans who are grossly counterproductive in the battle against poverty and economic regression. Those aptly described by you in the article “Anatomy Of A Kenyan MP “. In the west too, there are those who would rather the whole continent disappeared. But let us not criticise unfairly just because a “mzungu” has done what he can in the best way he knows how.
Your shot at him was unfair but normally I see your points.
66. Curious
(6 Comments) | August 15th, 2005 at 5:40 pm
The article “suffering developing countries” can be found on:
http://culturefusion.blogspot.com
67. tHiNkEr’S rOoM » Blog Archive » Ask M
(No Comments) | February 15th, 2006 at 2:35 pm
[...] They’re all my children. My favourite are under the header ‘Best Of M’. The ones I like mostMe & My AssLiar LiarGet Real:Global Politics 101The Name’s Al. Al KoholicLive Aid? Please!Cabinet Tales ! through IV [...]
68. Letters from China
(No Comments) | July 14th, 2006 at 2:20 pm
Africa, Bob Geldof, China…
Last year Ethan Zuckerman was sceptical about Live 8 and apparently in the minority. A year on, the Telegraph reconsiders the legacy of the big event and Richard Dowden, the director of the Royal African Society, was quoted as saying:Economic…
69. Joseph Wamicha
(1 Comments) | June 5th, 2007 at 8:53 am
Excellent article.
‘We Africans’ have to come up with our own strategies to get ourselves out of our languishing poverty. However, there are some truly genuine people in the G8 who do truly wish to help. They would then find solid policies and infrastructure that ‘we Africans’ have set up, through which they can help. Only those who help themselves can be helped.
That said Africa does need outside help.
Here are some really interesting lectures by Jeffrey Sachs:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio4/reith2007/
70. Angelina Julie
(1 Comments) | June 10th, 2007 at 4:58 am
I am glad to post my views and points in this blog, but I must say that webmaster of this blog has done a very great job to make his blog more informative and more discussable but unfortunately everthing is same here that more than 80% in this and other blogs post their comments for making spam!!!, so i will really all this spam links to google band tool, because webmaster makes blogs for making discuss and for sloving each other problems. thanks http://www.gordoniihoodia.net
71. politik-digital.de
(No Comments) | December 9th, 2007 at 10:06 pm
Kommentierte Linkliste Weblogs aus Afrika…
…