Kenya Burns!
29
January
Events over the past 5 weeks have afforded me much opportunity for introspection. From what I have seen, to what I have heard, to what I have read. I cannot tell a lie. I am deeply affected by the events that took place for the past 5 weeks. I asked what have they done? Almost 4 weeks ago. And it is clear that people just don’t realize what has been done to this country — every time they think they do it gets worse.
This election my M.O. was that I was going to see things for myself and not rely on the traditional media. And so I went out to capture the pulse of the country. Of course, I saw a lot more that I would never have imagined, more intimately than most; because unlike most people
- I actually went to KICC towards the tail end of the announcement that set things off. I fashioned my own Media badge (scrutiny was quite cursory) and took myself there. I saw with my own eyes doctored tally sheets. I saw the infamous 16A and remember laughing outright when the figure the chairman read out was absurdly different from what was on some of the actual forms.
- I actually visited some polling stations and saw clumsy attempts to modify tally sheets
- I actually went out and into the Mukuru slums a couple of days after the residents stoned our houses and forced us into an impromptu curfew. I have seen horrible things and heard horrible tales. I have inhaled quite a bit of teargas and my reflexes to sounds like gunfire have to be seen to be believed.
- I still go out to Mukuru even now. I tell you its one thing to see these people on TV and it is quite another to talk to them and share their experiences.
In fact that is what I think every man and woman of goodwill who is serious about helping should be doing. Personally I think we’ve had enough of these bullshit conferences, press briefings and what nots. Enough of them. The same things are said over and over again. What new things are said? People just go there, make the same old same old bleating for peace, then get into their 4×4s and drive to their cushy estates. I no longer attend these things because I fail to see the value that they add. There comes a point when you must stop talking and start doing.
You can’t appeal for peace on TV. You must do it face to face. So please, spare us these media briefings and press conferences. We can only get peace by making people see sense one at a time. So the more of us that do it, the sooner it will be done.
Some time back I shared my concerns that perhaps the youth have had a hand in the morass this country is currently in. Watching the footage of events in Nakuru and Nyahururu leaves me in little doubt.
Granted, this was started by politicians. The elections were just the flint that set alight the situation. However I refuse to absolve the participants of the mayhem of their share of the blame. The fact of the matter is that at the end of the day you must take responsibility for your actions.
If you threw stones, hacked people, burnt houses or looted then you are also to blame.
If you didn’t throw stones or hack or burn or loot but you spread hate through your blogs, your text messages, your emails and your conversations, please believe you are just as bad as the panga wielding youths. You are equally to blame.
It was absolutely chilling yesterday to watch footage of rowdy youths pulling men out of matatus and proceeding to lynch them.
I have for a long time been opposed to capital punishment. But now I ask myself would I really shed a tear if these murderers and looters in Eldoret. Kisumu, Nakuru, Naivasha, Molo, Kuresoi etc were strung up? I doubt it.
Questions
What I want to know is
- Where is the President? Mr Kibaki cannot have it both ways. If he insists he is the duly elected president then it is incumbent upon him to act accordingly. He must not only do something, he must be seen to be doing something.
- Where are our MPs? Why are they all here in Nairobi, and it is on record that they have only done a single day’s work? All MPs should be on the ground in their own constituencies doing their bit to ensure that this madness ends. We’ve had enough press conferences from comfortable hotels saying the same thing. Mr Kibaki should be in Othaya. Mr Odinga should be in Kibera. All their lieutenants should be at their constituencies moving from door to door campaigning for this foolishness to end. I won’t buy any arguments about government having to continue. What is there to govern?
- Where is the Church? I’m not impressed at all by any of the churches in Kenya. The Catholic Church, The Anglican Church, the Islamic community and the Independent churches have been very lethargic indeed. What happened to the men of faith who did not hesitate to speak for the people in word and in deed like Bishops Muge? Okullu? Gitari? Why are their successors so quietly lethargic?
- Why wasn’t the Army deployed in Eldoret 3 weeks ago?
Shattered Myths
- Kenya is an oasis of peace. Is it now?
- Kenyans are a deeply religious people. I find it difficult to reconcile this alleged deep devotion to The Maker, the innumerable filled churches and mosques and the images of brother turning against brother with crude weapons. It is bandied about that Kenya is 70% or so Christian. If this is so I can see much in the phrase “Jesus wept”.
- Kenya believes in the right of law. The ODM refuses to challenge the elections in court. While I understand their reluctance, it is also scoring an own goal because it can be argued that they are not going to challenge because they know they lost. Impasse right there. Also the PNU allege the ODM also committed electoral malpractice. Why have they not gone to court either?
Fueling The Fire
[ED]It would appear ODM Embakasi MP [ED]Mugabe Were was shot outside his compound. This is the absolute worst time for such a thing to happen.
AOB
My attention has been drawn to an online equivalent of a pissing contest. My response is exactly what it was before. There is nothing magical about blogging that absolves you from the responsibility to check your facts before you post them. There is nothing magical about it that makes it okay for you to say as you please without repercussion. Everyone has their own opinions on what blogging ought to be. For some it is a means to diary their exploits. For others it is a cash cow. For others it is a means to build castles in the air. For others it is an opportunity to be big fish in small ponds. For others it is a way to purge their souls. For others it is a way to express their creativity. For others it is a ticket to yet another blogging conference. For others like me — it is a way to express what I happen to be thinking.
But make no mistake about it. Whatever your reasons it is still incumbent upon you to be responsible with whatever you blog. My idea of responsibility is that if you are purporting to be speaking as someone telling people authoritatively what is happening on the ground, you’d best have your facts right as you write. Hoping that it turns out to be true later is not good enough. Hiding behind innuendo is not good enough.
Buzz words like ‘citizen media’ and ‘one man publishing press’ do not change a thing. Neither does pontification from behind podiums at conferences. At the end of the day bloggers are still human beings and must still be held responsible for their words and actions. Whether or not bloggers choose to get lost in their grandiose delusions of grandeur does not change a thing.
A WordPress installation does not exempt you from this any more than a calculator exempts you from knowing how to add.
A cursory glance at blogs today speaks for itself. Just read some of the blog posts that have been written over the past month. A good number make my skin positively crawl. What defence do all the authors of those ridiculous ‘letters’ have? Freedoms are not absolute. They have responsibilities as well.


1. Olive
(7 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 11:58 am
AMEN!!! Am soo with you on 100% of what you shared - if i was any closer i would be sitting on your lap!
2. Mwari
(7 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 12:43 pm
RE: AOB
Sounds just like the ODM/PNU impasse, (writing as once who recalls the matter at hand). Surely, it need not be that big an issue? Sounds like there is more else to it. I am so sensitive to any discord amongst Kenyans at the moment…mend up gentlemen, mend up. You are both good.
3. aegeus
(79 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 12:51 pm
this post is right on the money.
4. abelian
(53 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 12:54 pm
The common mwananchi is doing the killing, probably after being egged on by politicians or some other troublemaker. How do we make people realize that the violence is going to come back and bite them in the arse? Blocking the roads to Kisumu and killing the Luos means someone else will block the roads to Nairobi and business will come to a standstill, there will be no food, fuel, for upcountry.
How do we make the common man see that? How can we tell them that Kibaki or Raila will not be in that refugee camp waiting for yellow maize and salted porridge from the UNHCR?
5. JK
(25 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 1:29 pm
It’s hard to know what to say any more, but I’m glad that YOU still continue when the rest of us have lost our voices….Each time we think we’ve seen it all, something else happens that shocks us that much further. What we saw, people being pulled out of matatus and lynched, that image cannot leave my mind.
Keep safe hun, daring streak or not!
6. donworry
(48 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 1:59 pm
Just to echo my total support for all that you have said, M. I understand too what JK above has said because I seem to have lost my voice. What more can be said;
I understand the neccessity of responsible blogging and it would be wrong not to appear to be spreading fear, doom and gloom but patterns cannot be ignored… Why does it seem that every new atrocity being committed is even more despicable than the previous ones? Pulling ordinary raia out of mats and hacking them to death….what next?
…..Let us save it whilst there is still something worth saving
7. AtSanity'sEdge - also posting as EdgeOfSanity
(30 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 2:40 pm
Kenya burns.
senseless.killing.dying.
failure.leaders.voters.
hope.lost.renewed.lost.
I write.talk.dream.cry.pray.
Kenya still burns.
8. Mwangi
(49 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 2:53 pm
Thank you! You were honest! You were deep! Most of all you spoke from a place of caring about other people.
Thank you!
9. joe
(1 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 3:45 pm
M,
Couldn’t agree more.
I am dismayed at the things being posted in erstwhile respectable blogs. The flurry of sms and emails that all purport to give “the real picture” = “rumors and hate speech”.
Keep on exercising objectivity. Lord knows we need it at this time.
10. Jose
(19 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 4:33 pm
M,
I often agree with your thoughts. I like the prose, the style and the clear thought that goes into what you say. Today, I find that I must respectfully disagree with you on one thing, so please indulge my post.
Kenyans are indeed a deeply religious people. Indeed majority of Kenyans are practising Christians. Many Christians I personally know have been fasting and praying for peace, love and unity to be restored.
There has been a flare up of the kind we have never seen before. Brother has turned against brother. Women have been widowed and kids orphaned. Many women have lost their virtue to marauding youths, and many men have lost their lives to these same youths. All in all, a great wave of evil has surged and raged across our country.
But, M, please travel round the city and the country, and visit a few homes. You will find simple people abstaining from meals. The idea is that the food so saved can go towards feeding those who are displaced. Visit churches on Sundays, and indeed the mosques on their day of worship. You will hear a loud shout and prayer for peace. You will also hear stories of personal sacrifice - of Kenyans who have hosted members of other tribes who have been displaced. Of Kenyans who have set apart their savings to feed and clothe those who have been displaced. Of Kenyans who are eager to assist in restoring calm in their land, but do not quite know who to see or how to go about it.
This softer side does not get much media coverage. The Kikuyus who are crying coz Kalenjins were killed in Naivasha, or the Kalenjins who are crying coz Kikuyus were killed in Eldoret do not get their faces onto TV. The deeply religious who are fervent in their prayer for their country are not newsworthy and do not make it to the newspapers or the TVs.
Marauding youths, sharp machetes and burning houses - now those are newsworthy. Dead and dying people, destroyed property and livelihoods - now these make great headlines! But we are not getting the complete picture.
The people carrying out these evil acts are NOT the majority of Kenyans. They are NOT acting on behalf of the majority of Kenyans. Their numbers may be large, but remember we are a population of 34 million.
If I was to hazard a guess, no more than 200,000 Kenyans have been involved in these beastly acts. I could be wrong on the number but not the fact. I know I’m right about this - there are far more Kenyans, indeed 10 if not 100 times more Kenyans, who want peace than those who want war.
So I disagree with you, my cyberfriend, that the myth has been shattered. Kenya is religious, and our devotion to God and to peace will triumph in the end. I believe that with everything that I have. Even so, may the peace and love and unity come quickly!
God bless Kenya.
11. Seasonsandreasons
(14 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 4:58 pm
A lot of blogs sprung up around the last quarter of 2007. Many of these were apparent propaganda machines, some of them were news blogs and a few were of noble intent.
Once the comments come in, the true intentions become clear.
I just find that I cannot blog without getting a snide comment on an opinion. I try not report on news(except from today when I woke up at 4 am and probably was the first to break the Were issue)
My heart aches for Kenya and I feel so helpless.
12. J
(1 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 5:53 pm
Talking of facts, its Mugabe Were, not Mugambi!
13. Kirima
(58 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 6:00 pm
HEAR HEAR! You couldn’t have said it better.
14. Maina Muhanga
(4 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 6:10 pm
Mr Blogger,i hope you realize too though you seek justice you hands are not clean.i have for the last 5 years read your hate campaign against the Kibaki administration.At some point it looked like innocent banter but as you may have realized words-spoken or written can be very potent.
15. renee
(5 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 7:09 pm
Thinker, u have ur finger on the heart of the nation. The violence in Kenya has got me thinking about my ethnicity/tribe and how all the stereotypes we have encouraged as we grow up has affected us. It is time to form departments of ethnic/tribal studies at our colleges to come up with ideas on how to develop a framework to discuss this issues in a healthy environment. Kudos thinker for saying what some of us are thinking but are unable to find the words to cry out with.
16. msaniixl
(73 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 7:28 pm
@Maina Muhanga ….Hate campaign????? wow. You must be reading another blog.
M. Salute for powerful piece. The blogs acting/acted irresponsibly should be ashamed of themselves.
17. wathiifm
(61 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 7:32 pm
It’s about time we preached peace…I’m holed up in Garissa and this people were asking me,why are we fighting yet we were the one’s who showed them the way to live in peace n harmony.
18. toiyoi
(99 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 7:34 pm
@Jose
ON “there are far more Kenyans, indeed 10 if not 100 times more Kenyans, who want peace than those who want war”. You are wrong. Where are they? Why are they not being heard? Is this not the moment for them to come out and their voices of reason be heard? Where are they?
The bitter truth? These so called youths are the foot soldiers of your silent majority (who are really cowards, wanting to have it both ways). In these people’s hearts, they hope these youths enable “their victory” (i.e. the silent majority’s) to be achieved. Case in point: KP reports that there are cases where people are being asked their “tribe” at KNH before being provided with treatment! Those offering treatment at KNH are educated RN’s and MPH and Dr’s?
On “Kenyans are indeed a deeply religious people. Indeed majority of Kenyans are practising Christians.”
-religion does not translate to true christinity. -BTW, if only 5% of kenyans were true practicising christians, their prayers would have been heard a long time ago, and you would have heard the clergy preaching righteousness from their pulpits( not politics), but we all know that most of the clergy is no better than the Kenyan politicians.
- Now assuming, you know how God operates, has it ocurred to you that He may perhaps be allowing this mayhem to occur? You do not think so? Why?
19. acolyte
(171 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 9:47 pm
A Well written post, this issue reminds me of how two children were once playing with matches and lit a small fire. Only for the flames to begin engulfing the dry grass around them and become a fully blown wildfire that they couldn’t control that even began to burn their village.
We know who the children are and we are the village.
This may sound weird coming from a maverick like me but a blog is a very powerful tool, we all have freedom of speech but we should be careful of the consequences of what we say, you can’t say you are committed to peace when you are fanning the flames of war with your speech.
As for faith it seems that once politics came in the door, God went out of the window. What galls me more is the silence of the church. They were loud during Moi’s time but now hardly a peep is being heard from them.
20. abelian
(53 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 10:05 pm
Toiyoi is right, Kenyans are church/mosque goers but not Christians/Muslims… some of the most terrible atrocities have been commited in Churches.
The problem is that reasoning with a raging mob is very hard, these problems have to be solved at the core.
My relationship with my Luhya and Luo college mates has become strengthened and we cry and drown our sorrows together.
If only my countrymen would stop and reflect for a minute
21. Ishara
(16 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 10:45 pm
M, I await your denouncement and condemnation.
This illegitimate government and the bungling band of buffoons at the ECK have hastily implemented the costly “cover your ass” public relations campaigns through the media with the full expectation being to discredit any and all claims of irregularities and illegalities associated with our presidential election.
So M, in keeping with their line of reasoning:-
1. You are deaf (you did not hear what you heard).
2. You are blind (you did not see what you saw).
3. You are dumb (you must NOT speak about what you heard or saw) and it is irresponsible to contribute to further confusion/misinformation.
4. Just like the EU and EAC election observers you are biased (you have been either paid off or are jostling for political favour).
5. Finally, a winner was declared, the elections are over, a working government is in place and we must move on (skirmishes only affect 3% of the Nation, the Police is on hand and in full control of the situation).
I think I’ve set them off to a running start there-now watch them come creeping out of the woodwork.
22. renee
(5 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 10:54 pm
i want to sing
but what song do i sing?
i want to dance
but my feet can’t move!
i want to cry
but my eyes are dry!
i want to scream
but who will listen?
23. toiyoi
(99 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 11:32 pm
@Ishara
good convictions you have there. Now, do the manly thing: go back to kenya and plead your case with the 3% causing the skirmishes. You are wasting your time with those who read these blogs…
24. toiyoi
(99 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 11:49 pm
@renee
Literally, here is a song for you: http://www.kenya.fm
25. toiyoi
(99 Comments) | January 29th, 2008 at 11:52 pm
@M,
You took my note to Ishara too literally..you need to get some rest
26. Kenyanchick
(13 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 12:05 am
Amen, amen, AMEN! I couldn’t have said it better.
I’ve also been bewildered, angered and just plain pissed off by all those blogs that have been spitting hatred and which now, remarkably, are “mourning” Kenya and “wondering how the violence started.”
Write on, M. Write on.
27. Ali
(14 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 12:58 am
This is one of the most thoughtful blogs i have ever read from a Kenyan in recent days.
We Kenyans are proud to count people like you as our fellow citizens.
I hope we all can borrow a page from your insight into the current situation
For me , there are two root reasons behind this madness.
1.The Rift Valley land issue created by the late Kenyatta.-this has always existed but politicians and media in the past preferred sweeping it under the rag.
2.Kibaki illegitimate presidency. I am not an ODM
supporter by any account and yet i am a firm believer in the truth. I Sas this things unfold on TV with my own eyes. Whatever else happened or didn’t happen,Kibaki stole the elections.Kibakis supporters lived in denial but had we accepted this truth , non of this would have happened save for parts of rift valley.
Even if there was a doubt as to who really won the elections, the solution was very very simple.
REPEAT THE ELECTIONS AGAIN PERIOD. Yet Kibaki was against this, for those of you who missed the KICC/ECK Saga, this is another clear indicator that Kibaki lost. Why isn’t he willing to do the elections again? no brainer.
Its a pity people even had to debate with Kibaki supporters, about whether Kibaki won or lost. Its a shame we even have Kofi Anna trying to resolve this issue.The hypocricy involved is why people are dying. The total diregard for human life for the sake of power. The greed and arrogance of a certain click of people. The absolute dictatorship by a rejected Man is why people are dying.
It is time for Kibaki to exercise the humanity in him. For the sake of our Nation, for the love of our brothers from Kikuyu/luo/kalenjin/maasai Community,For all the good times we have had together,For all the intermarriages between different communities,For our eternal co-existence, For the sake our our childrens children.For our identity, For our homeland….,MR Kibaki please do the right thing and either step down or make way for a rapid re election re run.Going to court is not an option when the judges are not independent of Mwai Kibaki.So stop telling the opposition to go to court.
People like me who are independent of both ODM/PNU just want to see the truth.
28. abelian
(53 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 1:08 am
@Toiyoi,
Listen to my mother’s favourite gospel hymn, I dedicate to all Kenyans who are facing a violent and uncertain future.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w_4mcxicHM4&feature=related
29. daniel.waweru
(1 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 1:20 am
Dazzling post.
Still, I can’t help but feel you’ve been very unfair to the churches. Just two examples: Cornelius Korir sheltered thousands of people in Eldoret; at the Coast, Muslim leaders took the initiative in calling for dialogue between communities and a cessation to the violence.
30. Silaha
(6 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 1:54 am
M:
Thank you, I thought I was losing my mind! There did not seem to be any level headed reasonable people left anywhere any more, least of all the blogosphere.
Here is an IM convo with a close Gikuyu friend of mine (who I hitherto, and still to some extent, considered to be a progressive moderate). If he is getting to be so extremist God bless us all:
HIM: Luos must go.
ME: Nonsense.
HIM: We don’t need them I am convinced of that.
ME: You should not say that, we do need them. They are as Kenyan as the Gikuyus.
HIM: We are as Kenyan as them.
ME: True, but the Gikuyu did steal this election. No doubt.
HIM: But the truth is we manage resources better than they do. They stole also.
ME: There is no evidence of that.
HIM: We are all thieves but we make better thieves.
ME: LOL.
31. Vedec
(6 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 2:13 am
What is this repeated talk of a working govt I keep hearing? As we speak, Kenya may have a govt, legit or not is another story, but a working govt???! HELL NO!!! Not with the half-hearted, subjective measures it has employed in dealing with the mire we find ourselves in today. We can all mention more than one pragmatic approach to end all this madness surrounding us, none of which is yet to be implemented. I believe the govt is deliberately doing nothing, hoping that by ignoring the situation, everything will simmer down. A cabinet was even named with all the key positions filled! So is it ineptitude plaguing them or what?! Everybody, friends and foes alike admit that Kibaki’s forte is fence-sitting, but I wish he acted like the “duly elected” president he calls himself. Beyond the press statements through Alfred Mutua, has he shown any leadership? All he is proving is that he really is not made of presidential material, because if he was, he’d have used the resources at his disposal to bring all this to an end. We have failed to learn from the history of the likes of Somalia, and could end up just like them…unless something happens to change our course.
32. Ali
(14 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 2:41 am
I do believe that if all the bloggers and writers of Kenya can b e reasonably level headed, this violence could be tamed.The problem is we too are spreading hate by posting non-truths and incitements.The sand reality is Kenyans are very biased when it comes to their “tribes”.As we all know most Kikuyus have been fiercely defending Kibaki in these blogs and forums.
What has surprised me the most is the reaction of the younger the better educated Kenyans. Despite our exposure to the outside world and city life, we have proved to be quite primitive in our thinking.That has been a total surprise to me. i couldn’t have guessed in a million years that someone raised in Nairobi,Kisumu or Mombasa would have this narrow mindedness.
In Nai, we the children of parents from different ethnicity grew up together like real brother
and sisters.We played together,ate together,suffered together, fought together, laughed, cried, spoke sheng, a swahili based language that borrows from all this different ethnicities.
I remember my Kikuyu childhood friends and how we were so close.Some we are still close and in touch….How could i hate my friends Wawesh, Albert, Ngash, Njugush, Wambui,Mapei, ans Irosh?
These were my family, even though i am not a Kikuyu.. Many Luo kids and luhyas in Nai even learned how to speak Kikuyu….To date my best friend is aa Kikuyu guy we grew up together. I just cant imagine waking up and turning against them.They are part of me.
And this is the case all over Kenya. Friends are turning on friends.. Neighbors on neighbors.
Brothers on brothers..
This has to stop and the sense will have to come from us, the integrated Kenyans who grew up in Nai,Mombasa and other big cities.We must separate ourselves from the Rural Kenyans who know no better. Then we can convince them through action, to stop the madness.
33. Matofa
(1 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 7:10 am
M,
We are blessed to have a thinker such as you who can weave the complex situation we have today into a logical thread. I really feel for us Kenyans, but I recall my visit to Uganda and Rwanda in 2004. These countries absolutely adored Kenya and seemed to hold us in very high esteem. Rwanda was even more ridiculous, as Kenya shillings were preferred to the almighty dollar. Though one thing that seemed to resonate with all and curiously struck me was their contempt for Kenyan behaviour. Most East Africans claimed we were uncivilized and our Matatu culture seemed to permeate in some of our behaviour.Of course i vehemently denied these accusations, “Someone must have paid you to taint the good name of Kenyans” I said. Only to be confronted with the grim truth once I crossed over to our ‘peaceful’ country. The one thing I did not do was live in denial and dismiss our fragile society. We did not respect each other, we had total disregard for the law e.g. urinating in public, we drove like maniacs, and common courtesy to say the least was absent. Now, transport these tendencies to our current day leadership and we can see the apple does not fall far from the tree. Anyway say hello to the family,and I intend to run somewhere in the 2027 elections on a Kandanda ticket for presidency. By the way, we are missing again with our sorry uniforms at the Africa Cup of Nations. Only Kenyans are able to f_ck up our stingo/style when the world is watching. Pole for the incoherent message, but this baridi in exile is freezing my brain.
34. Kenya1
(5 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 7:13 am
I personally think that the cause is being lost because moderates, who truly are the silent majority, are not willing to come out of the wood-work and put their proverbial foot down. We have for too long allowed the imbeciles on the blogs and in the streets define other people’s perceptions of us as communities. This has to stop. Kenyans need to WAKE THE EFF UP!!! …and we should start this by calling people out for their bigotry. If you consider yourself a moderate, if you believe that Kenya is a community of thirty-plus million brothers and sisters, then do this as a patriotic duty. Do this preferably to a bigot that will no doubt assume you share the same political, social and moral beliefs because you share a tribal affiliation.
It does not matter how many new liberations we agitate, how many new constitution we write, we have to, at the individual level, confront the evil that is bigotry in ourselves and those immediately around us.
We as moderates need to let these knuckleheads on the blogs know that we are on to them and we will not let them get away with their hate campaigns any longer. How come we can’t call them out in the same public forums? We all know who they are. Even you M of all people seem to be unwilling to do this, choosing to be diplomatic about it with a vague “some bloggers on the internet”. This coyness not only does the country a disservice but also serves to incriminate decent bloggers who have been objective from day one and at the same time pacify the hate mongers into thinking they are still under the radar. Let’s all start calling out the war mongers and exposing them. MASHADA.COM is probably the biggest of these and where all aspiring and established bigots go to convene. They have PNU bigots, ODM bigots, others in-between bigots, with some general anarchy bigots thrown in for good measure. Reading some of the posts there literary makes my stomach turn. Someone with the technical knowhow ought to database all that stuff as it might come in handy when sanity returns and some of the chicken undoubtedly come home to roost. The email forwards and text messages can also be reverse traced. We as a people ought to catalogue and archive these things, as they do Nazi literature and the like, as warning to future Kenyan generations to the destructive power of irresponsible speech, petty intolerance and outright ignorance.
35. Jose
(19 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 8:44 am
Toiyoi,
I case you missed what I said, I said that the reason the churches and the mosques and the good folk are not being heard as loudly as they ought to be is that their message of peace is NOT considered to be newsworthy.
And if you think that the armed gangs have the implicit approval of the silent majority, then I’m not sure which Kenya you are living in. Are you in Kenya in the first place?
The Kenya I’m living in is angry that their voice was muzzled and silenced in this election. They are VERY angry. But these Kenyans, i.e. the majority, do NOT want to harm their neighbours. Why is it you have not heard of Luos being killed in Embu, or in Meru or in Isiolo or in Wajir?
Have you heard of Kikuyus being killed en masse in Kisumu? You’ve seen buildings burn and businesses being looted, but have you heard of deaths and murders?
Is it because there are no Luos in Embu or in Meru? Is it because there are no Embus or Merus or Kikuyus in Kisumu?
They are there, in small numbers, but there all the same. They are not being targetted in these areas. Even in Eldoret, much has been made about the killings, but nothing is being made of the refuge that Kalenjins are offering Kikuyus, or Luhyas are offering Kikuyus and the vice versa.
Are these things happening? YES they are! Why, you ask, are we not hearing of them? COZ IT’S NOT NEWSWORTHY!!
I maintain, and I know it to be true, that there are MORE voices for peace and reconciliation than there are for violence. I know that people are smarting from a sham election, and they want to see justice done. But the majority values peace MORE than it values chaos.
I cannot get into the way God works and the way God thinks, because that discussion would consume all of cyber space. In any event, God’s word says that HIS thoughts are way beyond ours and HIS ways high above ours. So who can really say how God works.
But I know one thing, just because it is dark and evil seems to be on the ascendancy does NOT mean that people are not praying, fasting and believing. It does not mean that God is not hearing or even answering.
My simple point is this. More Kenyans want peace than those who want war. More acts of mercy are being done than the acts of violence. These acts of mercy will RARELY make it to the TV screens or the newspapers. If we wish to see change in our society, and that change is a move away from ethnic hatred, then WE, you and I, MUST be the change.
Those that are for peace are MORE than those that are for war. So peace will prevail. And Kenya, a multi-ethnic and diverse Kenya, will prevail.
If you don’t see it that way and you choose to dwell on the bad that’s happening, then it’s unfortunate. I persomally choose to focus on the good that’s happening. And quite frankly, a lot of good is happening in the midst of this evil.
36. Jose
(19 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 8:46 am
I came across this story. Its wisdom is manifest.
One evening an old Cherokee told his grandson about a battle that goes on inside people.
He said, “My son, the battle is between the two
“wolves” inside us all.
One is Evil. It is anger, envy, jealousy, sorrow, regret, greed, arrogance, self-pity, guilt, resentment, inferiority, lies, false pride,
superiority, and ego.
The other is Good. It is joy, peace, love, hope, serenity, humility, kindness, benevolence, empathy, generosity, truth, compassion and
faith.”
The grandson thought about it for a minute and then asked his grandfather: “Which wolf wins?”
The old Cherokee simply replied, “The one you feed.”
37. teego
(1 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 11:30 am
Once to every man and nation comes the moment to decide,
In the strife of Truth with Falsehood, for the good or evil side;
38. abelian
(53 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 12:54 pm
Jose,
Great story and very appropriate
39. Esther
(7 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 1:49 pm
M,
I totally agree with you on this post, and more importantly on the question of ‘preaching peace’ on TV. Interestingly this was also the subject of discussion on a breakfast show on an FM station here in Kampala today. Uganda is greatly affected by what’s happening in Kenya so of course its all eyes on Kenya at the moment. So one caller wondered why Kibaki and Raila were issuing peace statements on tv - he additionally observed that Kibaki seemeed to stutter as he READ his statement and he was wondering why he couldn’t just look the camera in the eye and speak from his heart or, even better, visit the violence areas. I was so embarassed I switched to another station… something about the truth hurting.
On the issue of a ‘working government’ what work exactly are they doing? Yesterday after I queued for 20 minutes at a petrol station in Kampala I got to the pump only to be told that I could only buy Ushs. 10,000/- worth of fuel. Considering that fuel costs 2,500 a litre, I could only get 4 (yes, FOUR) litres of fuel. Why? Because the highways in Kenya are highly insecure and impassable and there are 500 trucks stuck at Mlolongo with goods destined for the Great Lakes countries. Because the rail in Kenya has been vandalised so even using rail transport is out of the question. Pray tell, how do these ‘youth’ throw up ‘civilian roadblocks’ and get away with murder yet the police are unable to do anything about it? On Saturday I spoke to someone in Nairobi and we were saddened about the situation in Nakuru. He additonally mentioned that rumour had it that Naivasha was the next town to be targetted. We woke up on Sunday to the sad news that indeed Naivasha had been attacked in the wee hours of the morning. So, if this information was in the public domain, how come the security forces could not avert the attacks?
The grapevine becomes the choice source of information becasue none is forthcoming from the duly elected government. All we hear from Alfred Mutua is paid out adverts in the press asking the US/EU/UN etc to prove that Kibaki did not win. What’s wrong with this man? First up there are diplomatic channels that he can use to ask these questions. Second of all, what I’d like to know from his office is what the governemnt is doing to contain the security situation. What plans are there to resettle the displaced? (I doubt there are any plans in this regard. Isn’t it just the other day that the people in Jamhuri park were being ordered to leave? Leave and go where???) As M often states, however low you place the bar, stupidity always manages to slither beneath it. Also, how about some messages of peace from this office? Who reads the newspapers and watches tv anyway? Definitely not the people hacking others all over the country. How about some alternative communication channels with the appropriate message? Considering Alfred Mutua has a doctorate in communications, one would imagine he would know more about the psychology of communicaiton than most. If any of you sat in Mutua’s classes, I suggest you request a refund from the university - you were ripped off!
Another interesting thought was posed on the same show I was listening to this morning - that ethnicity in Africa is difficult to do away with primarily because our governments have failed to provide as strong a social support network as is provided by the clan/tribe etc. So all those guys in Jamhuri park will go calling on relas becasue their governemt is saying we don’t want IDP camps in Nairobi, get the hell out.
A Ugandan journalist visited the Kenyan refugee camps and wrote an article recently. One of the questions that the people in these camps were posing was, where is our governemnt? Whereas the Ugandan government had sent senior people to visit them, (the Ugandan Police Commissioner personally has been there twice to ascertain the security of the Kenyan refugees) the first time they saw anyone representing the kenyan government was on 18th jan - thats the first time our High Commissioner bothered to leave his comfortable home in Kampala to visit the refugees! They had been in the camps 3 weeks already.
I concur with M’s questions (and the editorial in today’s Nation)… this ‘duly elected’ government has some responsibilites to the citizenry and at this point in time we are calling them out, not for the legitimacy or otberwise of their victory, but for their inability to carry out their constitutional duties.
I also concur with Jose that a lot has been done away from the cameras to reach out to other people, unfortunatley the goodwill efforts don’t get any airime because as he been pointed out, they are not news worthy. It is true that more people want peace than those who want war. We will all do our bit, ponitificate, scream, cry… but what is unquestionable is that the buck stops with the ‘duly elected’ government of Emilio. This government not only needs to ‘work’ but also needs to be seen to be working. Actions indeed speak louder than words.
I am one of those who is proud to know that we have people like M in our midst. Kudos M!
40. mundu
(1 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 6:03 pm
something i’ve been waiting for at last. M, you say you saw those forged/doctored forms, i’m sure a good old hand at entrenching your reportage with facts did take a few snapshots of them. could you please post them. i know some fishy thing happened, but it would still be nice to see hard evidence of it.
41. kenya.fm
(7 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 6:59 pm
@jose,@Toiyoi
Who knows the mind of God? Neither of you. Neither do i, BUT, these i know:
(1)if there was true unity among kenyan Christians ( i.e. no kikuyu vs. Luo vs. Kalenjin christian etc ), their prayers would have been answered long ago, and Kenya would have been a relatively just (not perfect) society, and these events would not have happened.
( still, if such a thing would have occured, people would have sought shelter in the church, and they would have found it without conditions)
(2)The Christian God does allow/send war sometimes. You may desire peace, but sometimes, the only way for Him to get his people’s attention is to deny them the peace they seek so much ( surely your scriptures tell you these, gentlemen)
(3)if the Lord did punish his people (Israel) so severely, why would you imagine that Kenya may not deserve such a punishment if He deems it necessary.
(4)how do you know whether, through these, he is purifying and preparing his true church? Or do subscribe to the belief that God i so good that he can not allow evil?
NB: those who are not Christians, do not even bother to respond to these statements, they are way above your heads. No joke, just the truth.
42. Jose
(19 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 7:33 pm
@kenya.fm,
A number of good points you raise. I hesitate to answer because Christianity is a matter of faith. There is so much theology and interpretation out there, so I find it easier to stay away from theological discourse and to focus on true religion.
What is true religion? James 1:27 is emphatic on this point, and it reads as follows:
“Religion that God our Father accepts as pure and faultless is this: to look after orphans and widows in their distress and to keep oneself from being polluted by the world.”
If we as Kenyans in this season could focus on this, keeping ourselves from being tainted by negative ethnicity, and recommitting ourselves to loving our neighbours as we love ourselves.
If we as Kenyans could spend less time bickering over whose fault it is, and spend more time on caring for those who have been displaced widowed and/or orphaned.
If we could do these things, then slowly and surely peace will return to our land, and the healing process will begin.
So, please forgive me for not debating you on the very valid theological points you raise. I would love to do this at some point, but for now, I want to focus on the religion that is pure and blameless as the Apostle James suggested. To my mind, this is what Kenya needs in this season.
43. kenya.fm
(7 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 9:15 pm
@jose
Agreed. No need for debate. People do not eat debates. Debates bring no relief.
Just wanted to raise awareness that the situation has N dimensions from a spiritual point of view, and that if there is to be a main culprit, it is the watchmen ( the true CHURCH ), not the politicians or the angry youth: these know no better. The Christians, however, are in the know, being the light and the salt to their country first ( and businessmen and media celebrities and politicians later-if ever )
44. Ali
(14 Comments) | January 30th, 2008 at 10:58 pm
The indication of how to know whats Real:
When you feel a peaceful joy,you are near the truth.
Unquiet and off center, jealous or greedy,what you do seems pretentious and those around you insincere.
SPEAK THE CLEAREST TRUTH YOU KNOW AND LET THE DISEASE HEAL.
If words are tinged with lying, they’re like water dripping into a candle.The wick wont light.
The pleasure and rest of your love room will diminish.
Dear Kenyans.
Truth is the answer to ouR SITUATION today.Alot of people here claim to be for peace and want the best for our country Kenya. But so far no one is talking about TRUTH.It doesnt matter what we do, for as long as we do not speak in truth, the best we can do is just sweep the problem underneath the table for our children or childrens children to deal with in their time. Brothers and sisters, this is not the solution.
My challenge to all Kenyans reading this blog. Those of ODM and PNU, Kikuyus and Non-Kikuyus alike. Luos and non-Luos…Thise for and against.
My challenge to you is simple.
SPEAK THE CLEAREST TRUTH YOU KNOW AND LET THE DISEASE HEAL ITSELF.
When i say truth, i mean whatever you sincerely see as the Percive it to be, without any bias whatsoever.Say the truth to your self silently ,and in clarity first.And then fell free to tell it to others.
The truth shall set us free.
45. seinlife
(10 Comments) | January 31st, 2008 at 6:01 am
As spot on as you are on everything you have said, i would like to say the 2 butt nuggets i blame for selfishly masterminding the destruction of kenya are one, mwai kibaki and one, raila odinga. I would put this two nincompoops on a 10 minute ’stand in the corner’ timeout if i thought it would help.
46. edge.of.sanity
(30 Comments) | January 31st, 2008 at 9:38 am
Each day that passes with Kenya in it’s current state is a day too many for Kenyans to endure.
Kenyans who believe in and have enjoyed the relative peace, who harbored no ill will against their neighbors have been betrayed by their government, friends, neighbors and even family.
The government remains broken as the country fragments further; their questionably received mandate has been put to absolutely no use. The machinery of the “duly elected” government
has stallednever started at all. The opposition is not saying or doing much either. Calls for peace are few and are simply formalities that don’t resonate far enough to be heard and heeded. It would seem as if there’s nothing good to report out of Kenya because ‘bad news tv’ makes sure of it. If we believe that peace and good news from Kenya is newsworthy, we must take it upon ourselves to make it so.The information that has filtered from Kenya through the international media outlets has delivered mostly a pervading state of death, destruction, gloom and doom and the Kibaki-Raila stalemate. There’s no denying that the aforementioned is true, but we also have to acknowledge the humanity amid all of it. The whole truth needs to be told as it is on a day to day basis. I need to hear/read about it or I’ll lose it pretty soon.
People need to hear of all the good deeds of ordinary Kenyans; people who have been expected to be engage in senseless murder and all-round destruction along with equally gruesome counteroffensives due to their different tribes.
It’s time to get an affirmation from all media outlets, that an uncounted many have maintained their sanity at this critical juncture and defied the perceived truism in the Kenyan situation.
Most news stories and footage to date have depicted scenes of destruction and truly hateful activity.
Everybody is not killing everybody; it’s not that black and white. I’d like to have a repository for information about people who love Kenya and have done nothing to destroy it or the lives of fellow citizens.
Where are the stories of selfless Kenyans who have risked it all to save others? Where are the stories of sacrifice and brotherhood? How can we get the media to provide a sustained stream of Kenya’s peaceful side and what they’ve achieved during this madness? Maybe news that most are not fighting will help put of the fires. I’m sure some people are fighting because they feel that everyone else is. It’s worth a try, isn’t it? We’ve collectively blogged about everything else, haven’t we? The voices of the now silent guardians of peace in Kenya can be heard if we can all speak together at once in a positive voice beyond the internet.
Many internet blogs hosted by Kenyans have been allowed to become disgusting but thriving cesspools where hatemongers, bigots and the rest of the bottom-feeding crowd have found each other to celebrate the demise of fellow Kenyans as they spew their venomous rhetoric.
Kenyans on the ground should be encouraged to share their stories [via email, sms, blogs, word of mouth and unbiased news outlets] of how they’ve risen above the insanity or tell stories of others who have done the same. Kenya’s good heart still beats and we would like to feel it’s pulse.
Now, it’s just a matter of gathering and consolidating all that information and getting as many Kenyans who are online to access it and spread the word.
.
Thank you, M, and thinkers in the room.
i.am.H
47. Jogoo wa Shamba
(71 Comments) | January 31st, 2008 at 1:35 pm
Unconfirmed reports “MP for Ainamoi, Hon.David Too has been shot dead by a traffic policeman”.
Why am i getting a sinking feeling that someone is really hellbent on scuttling the ongoing mediation talks?
48. mudskippah
(14 Comments) | January 31st, 2008 at 3:27 pm
What’s going on was bound to happen sooner or later. If we find ‘peace’ and the real underlying issues, whatever they are, are not comprehensively dealt with it will happen again. Or maybe this time the chickens have really come home to roost. Sometimes it looks like a fire that will burn and burn until it consumes all its fuel and, or a pathogen that rages and only dies after it has killed its host.
Two MPs killed with 3 days of each other. Coincidence? Highly highly unlikely. Who’s doing this and what do they want?
49. Ali
(14 Comments) | January 31st, 2008 at 3:43 pm
We are all in this thing together. Its time for each and everyone of us to really look deep inside and identify our responsibility in what is going on.
As long as we listen to our inner voice, as long as we accept truth, Kenya will be fine.
We should all speak the one language of truth, not just of the outcome of the elections but truth on all the matters involved.Truth about tribalism, poverty, religion, greed, power, friendship, neighbors, etc.
Speak your truth clearly.
50. Abelian
(53 Comments) | January 31st, 2008 at 5:28 pm
Just as I begin to hope things are cooling down something else comes along and shatters that hope. Another MP shot dead! I am reaching a point where I am about to give up….
Who is stoking this violence and what is their aim? Could it be just an unfortunate accident? This is definitely more than a rigged election
51. seinlife
(10 Comments) | January 31st, 2008 at 7:57 pm
I read somewhere that the shooting of the MP was over a ‘domestic dispute’. A dead man is nothing to be overlooked but god i hope it was a domestic dispute and not politically motivated.
52. TK
(10 Comments) | January 31st, 2008 at 11:48 pm
See the link below to understand why the middle class should be very worried if a solution in not found soon…
http://www.nationmedia.com/dailynation/nmgcontententry.asp?category_id=25&newsid=115736
53. edge.of.sanity
(30 Comments) | February 1st, 2008 at 12:33 am
Thinkers in the room,
It’s not beyond the realm of extreme possibilities that this was indeed, a crime of passion, as reported by the NYT or is it? This second murder has occurred at the worst possible time and the result was to be expected. Of course, there’s no good time for a murder, period.
It’s all too easy to link the two murders and the language of the opposition leaders is not helping to control the mob mentality. This event could be domestic, political or both and the opposition are using the uncertainty surrounding it to their advantage. These marauders are helping to maintain the paralysis of the government which is what the opposition wants. The mobs have their implicit approval, I dare say.
One can only hope that the populous will remember this come next election season. Most of these characters will still be out there looking for votes.
Thank you.
I.am.H
54. Ali
(14 Comments) | February 1st, 2008 at 2:19 am
edge.of.sanity,
We can never know for certain what exactly happened to Mr Too, but what we know is this:
1.The police man was married with children so if this woman was his lover, she was a mistress to him.
2.Mr Too was a friend to the late husband of the lady .
In my experience with life, i have never seen coincidence pick such an opportune time- with the Kenyan violence,two days after the death of another ODM MP?
55. kenya1
(5 Comments) | February 1st, 2008 at 3:39 am
“Where are the stories of selfless Kenyans who have risked it all to save others? Where are the stories of sacrifice and brotherhood? How can we get the media to provide a sustained stream of Kenya’s peaceful side and what they’ve achieved during this madness? Maybe news that most are not fighting will help put of the fires. I’m sure some people are fighting because they feel that everyone else is. It’s worth a try, isn’t it? We’ve collectively blogged about everything else, haven’t we? The voices of the now silent guardians of peace in Kenya can be heard if we can all speak together at once in a positive voice beyond the internet.”
edge.of.sanity,
I really LIKE your idea. But it seems like the third estate has completely failed Kenyans.
Question is, are you willing to do this with me (and anyone else interested) as a project, where we could solicit and publish these true heroic stories in a blog? It could be a serene place where Kenyans can come to replenish their strength and affirm our faith in humanity and our Kenyan identity. I’m willing to put in the time and effort into such a noble cause.
56. Ali
(14 Comments) | February 1st, 2008 at 4:17 am
TK,
I just read the very interesting Nation article you linked. I can totally see that happening, you don’t even have to look at the Congo example, Just look at the spiraling Nairobi crime as an example.
I remember when i was growing up in Nai in the 80s and 90s , crime was mostly a poor mans problem.
It rarely happened in Lavington, Kileleshwa, Parklands, Muthaiga etc.
Then something interesting happens in the mid 90s. A daring Criminal named ‘Rasta” a.k.a Wanugu(whatever his name was), and two others, successfully robbed standard bank and won the ensuing gunfight against the police. He went on to elude capture for almost 2 years.
This was the turning point for crime in Nai, Criminals were inspired and started looking for opportunities beyond the ghetto.Actually lots of armed criminals decided not to “work’ in their own neighborhoods.Criminals in Nai usually despise those who rob people in their own neighborhood.
Bank Robberies were common but mostly unsuccessful..The middle class and rich had long ignored crime problems because they often thought that their wealth automatically protected them, crime was seen as a poor peoples problem. poor against poor.Despite the fact that most wealthy neighborhoods in Kenya are bordered by slums.
Today, without notice, crime in Nairobi has caught the middle class and rich off guard. Thugs venture deep into the heart of the wealthy on regular basis.Some time even going as deep as their bedrooms. Car jacking became common with most of the victims being the so called middle class.The government and the elite simply have been defeated by the poor Criminals.The police and security have no answers. Crime cannot be contained…
In short, crime is a bi-product of poverty. Kenya’s class ism and elitism often looks down at the poor and totally ignore their plight.
They have always thought that poverty was a poor peoples problem. Now they have to think again, as poverty comes knocking on their doors FREQUENTLY with the cries of AK 47s and the tears of bullets.
Without a doubt if the violence continues, the middle class and wealthy will not be spared.Its only a matter of a very very short time before the poor come knocking with machetes.
57. TK
(10 Comments) | February 1st, 2008 at 7:13 am
Ali,
That is a very good analysis on why the middle class, the rich and their families in the diaspora need to be really worried if a solution is not found soon, and I mean very soon.
One thing I noticed is that the government of Kenya doesn’t seem to have very good strategists. I wonder if this resulted in their inability to foresee their tremendous election loss, the post election violence and their inability to contain the violence. Thoughts? I would like urge Kenyans in the diaspora to reach out to affected Kenyan families and promote peace/healing among the Kenyans their communities. My friends, it’s ok to have different political opinions but it NOT ok to kill a fellow Kenyan.
58. edge.of.sanity
(30 Comments) | February 1st, 2008 at 10:08 am
@Ali - When all the impossibilities have been eliminated, whatever remains, however improbable, must be closer to the truth. If after that more than one explanation remains, then more investigating must be done. That’s what should be done in MP Too’s case before dangerous conclusions are made but it’s a little too late for that.
The opposition has already independently “investigated” this murder and found the government guilty.
Both the government and opposition are engaged in a covert war with the murdering youths are their unpaid foot soldiers.
Sure enough, MP Too’s murder is a major coincidence and a crisis management nightmare but those who have concluded that it’s a political assassination pending an investigation are fanning the flames.
On poverty and crime…I concur. It’s time for Kenya’s middle and upper classes to speak up before the rock-throwing-machete-waving-AK47 firing marauders make it to their front yards. Those posh neighborhoods are not portable; they aren’t going anywhere.
There are too many Kenyans who have quietly approved of the violence and are egging on their poorer, less educated and common sense deficient tribesmen to harm those of a different tribe…just because.
@TK - If the names in the piece about Congo were changed, it would be Kenya’s recent past, present and almost certain future. I’m very, very worried.
@Kenya1 - YES, I’d be willing to put in the effort to get these stories out. I published a variation of my above entry at this blogsite on Wednesday morning after I had done my internet rounds catching up with everything and was so furious about the new developments at the time…I signed up and started typing. I might have to edit it to reflect the cause.
Thinkers in the room, are you willing to help in tracking down these stories and blogging until our keyboards fade? Any and all ideas are welcome.
I sincerely believe that the sustained voices of many speaking at once will be heard. Those who have the power are sitting on their hands with their thumbs up their [insert "butts" here]. I think we owe it to our country to try and mollify the monster inside our brethren who have lost their way however futile the effort may seem. The healing can’t begin until there’s a reasonable level of calm [or even better, an all-inclusive calm].
Thank You, M & Thinkers in The Room.
I.am.H
59. edge.of.sanity
(30 Comments) | February 1st, 2008 at 11:25 am
TK, I know you directed your response at Ali but I have to chime in here. Our spurious imitation of a government is dominated by a rabble of the same turn of mind - devious, selfish, unthinking and grossly incompetent. These pseudo-elected and appointed officials aren’t there to perform their civic duty, they’re there to use that opportunity to steal with impunity or benefit themselves alone in other ways. The smart ones among them are powerless and the powerful are thoughtless.
They [strategists] definitely foresaw the election results and that’s why they were marred by irregularities. I don’t think the nefarious activity [some proven] was spontaneous and random at best.
I don’t think that the strategists were caught unawares by the eruption of violence either. I think they expected some localized unrest which would quickly come to pass and become yesterdays news. They just never expected things to get this far and go on for this long and therefore weren’t poised to deal with the fallout.
If we are assuming that they are the forces of good, then they are pretty much the worst strategists. On the other hand, if we look at them as them as the contemptible bunch that they are, then they did their job and don’t care about the people.
They’ve pretty much abandoned helpless Kenyans to fend for themselves against the monster they’ve unleashed. A ‘Chief of Police’ not in full control of the force is no Chief of Police and the same applies to the Commander-in-Chief. The government has failed to live up to it’s duties; it’s clearly I-M-P-O-T-E-N-T.
We are in accord on the following point.
Together with the middle class, Kenyans in the diaspora should reach out but in a united voice [I'm not yet sure how]. One voice makes a difference but it is easily stifled. How do we proceed?
——
I.am.H
60. Shiroh
(31 Comments) | February 1st, 2008 at 11:49 am
M, i do agree with you on most points. However i wonder is it only what you saw in Nairobi that is important.
I know several people who in the RV and Nyanza witnessed the spread of hate leaflet all over the campaign period.
The spreaders of those hate campaigns why were they never stopped. Why did every community suddenly start seeing each other as friends/enemies.
A lot went down and not just in KICC
61. Nakeel
(70 Comments) | February 1st, 2008 at 12:50 pm
Totally agree with you. Big salute. I saw Franklin Bett say all the Rift Valley MPs have agreed to go back to their constituencies and spread peace but in the evening they were all rushing to Nairobi.
62. Ray
(1 Comments) | February 1st, 2008 at 2:08 pm
I have heard the questions asked, “What can we do?” or “How do we make the common wananchi realize that they are the losers?”, etc.
Here are two articles highlighting peace-making initiatives by ordinary Kenyans on the ground. In my opinion, this is the way to actually answer these questions, not in words but in actions. This is indeed food for thought and a challenge for us all.
http://www.pambazuka.org/en/category/comment/45762
http://www.africanews.com/site/list_messages/15332
63. Carol
(5 Comments) | February 1st, 2008 at 6:32 pm
I think its a high time we stopped attacking each other in the name of ‘kikuyu’ or ‘luo’.
One could be kikuyu but did not vote for Kibaki or a luo who did not vote for Raila!
If anything does it matter?Every Kenyan has a right to vote to whoever they decide and no one should accuse them for their choice.
Now let our leaders stop hiding in their cosy houses in Nairobi’s fancy estates, but go to their constituencies to calm things down.
And police,oh my do not abuse your position you are there to serve kenyans but not to go against them.
My eyes are dry too!I cry no more!
God Save Kenya!
That is great M
64. Ali
(14 Comments) | February 2nd, 2008 at 4:01 am
An interesting question for us Kenyans to ask ourselves-What is peace? Is it the conditions we were living in prior to the elections? Or is is the absence of violence?
I am sorry to say this without being
missunderstood but as far as i am concerned, Kenya lost its peace long time ago- 1992 to be exact.This was the year when the so called first “democratic” multi-parties elections happened.
Aids became an household disease in Kenya on this same year, the dollar moved from 30s to 70s, Molo clashes erupted, Somali had just collapsed into a civil war a year earlier,Alongside the refugees, automatic weapons also found refuge at the hands of Kenyan criminals.Very many significant changes took place in this year- ironically, this was year we were officially introduced to “democracy”.
I remember how,long before this current situation, my heart would pump with fear whenever i found myself riding on a Matatu from the east side of Nairobi city any time past dark. I remember the fear on everybody’s face and the silent thought of -who could be the gangster within the Matatu. I remember how the fear would still creep up on me on my walk home from the matatu stop. I remember in Nai, how sunset scattered people. The rushing for safety that became our every day life. The constant feeling that being struck by criminals was imminent.
I remember driving to Umoja with a friend and while waitng for our host, we had to step out of the car to avoid being caught up by criminals in case they wanted our car.
i remember the daily car jacking, the shootings, the assassinations, the weekly and sometimes daily bank robberies, the maggings, the rapes, the dangerous corners, the scavenging chokoras, the scam artists, the thousands of prostitutes lining up K street at night…
I remember how a lady friend who had picked me up from the Airport, kept jumping red light because in Nairobi, stopping at a red light sometimes meant death of just a simple encounter with the gangsters.
Everyday in Nairobi,i had to deal with the subject of fear. There has, since 1992, always been a real threat somehow.
I Knew Kenya was at war, when one day after surviving one of my daily fears of late night Matatus, i got word that my lady friend could have been cheating on me.Just the mere suspicion brought in another set of fear all together-That of Aids. At this point i saw life in Nai as no better than Mogadishu at the time.Not to say they are comparable, but both cases breed a fearful life.
Kenya was never at peace- this is an illusion.
A Gorrila war between the gangsters and those who have has been on going for a while now.
If you don’t believe me, just observe your day to day policemen, they don’t walk with pistols. They carry G3S and AK47s. This are battlefield weapons.In peaceful countries police walk with no weapon at all or small pistols like .38 revolvers.
Now we enter into a new situation, the ongoing war with gangsters has never been addressed. We don’t even talk about it. Yet this is our day to day reality in various parts of Kenya.
Gangs like Mungiki have prospered in recent time, and this events make them even more bold. As we speak, Mungiki is already imposing a dressing code on Kikuyu women in Naivasha-no trousers.
Yet, with all the danger that they present to Kikuyus first, They now enjoy a even wider Kikuyu support who are increasingly accepting them as the kikuyu army.The golden question is, can Kikuyu as a people co-exist with their own Mungiki army? Only time will tell.
The main problem is not our leaders. The problem has to be us the people. The leaders come from among us and are only a reflection of ourselves.
Our minds are not right. We suffer from short attention span as a people, We have a memory problems and above all our mind are easily swayed.Just like small children and candy stories.We have no way of seeing things clearly and we hate seeing thing as they are instead we prefer illusions. We are in a make-belief state.Totally brainwashed to a point we dont know left from right. Very few of us actually have functioning brains. We are taught to believe that
using complex English words and good grammar is how you become smart. We think that you have to have a title to use your brain- If you are not “educated” , you have no right to think. The so called educated Africa are stranded in their little boxes called lawyers, doctors, engineeres, etc. And when opportunity presents itself, like in these recent events, we quickly realise that even our so called “educated” people are just as dumb if not dumber. Listen to Ngugi wa Thiongo on this subject. or This Luo professors and scientists…
Peace will be achieved only if we learn to take things at face value. Call a spade a spade and not a big spoon.
As long as we do not seek justice, Kenyans will not know peace.We might stop the machete war but the daily gangster war continues. The Guerilla struggle continues.
65. Andrew
(3 Comments) | February 2nd, 2008 at 9:25 am
Even though we current have a crisis, I think we allow this to happen.
When we allow organized gangs to exist with no punishments from the law, they grow. Some take a life of their own. Politician had weaken the laws to take care of this issue.
Take America. Organise crime did become a problem. Was it use by politicians? Yes but when the cost become to high on the society that is when action was take against them.
Do we have laws against organize crime?
What about gains from those crime?
What about funding? Or those folks that are funding these groups.
Lets talk about peace and also talk about stopping the circle that create the insecurity.
66. kenya1
(5 Comments) | February 2nd, 2008 at 9:31 am
Edge of sanity,
I checked out the site, i like it, all set and ready to go. This whole thing is happening at the worst time for me personally — but what crisis is ever considerate? Let’s do this. hit me up at onekenya2008@yahoo.com and we can hammer out some details.
Ali,
I like the way you think… level heads are few and far in between. Are you interested in kick starting our little patriotic project?
67. Ali
(14 Comments) | February 2nd, 2008 at 4:50 pm
@Kenya1,
Thanks a lot for the offer. I am definitely interested in a patriotic project. We as Kenyans need to promote awareness. The underlying problems affect all of us, rich and poor alike.
There is a need to address the issues in whole, not just in part. At the end of the day we all want to live in real peace and eliminate or reduce the fears of mainly crime/violence, negligent road accidents and Hiv Aids .This is the common interest of all Kenyans.
We all know we can live together in harmony despite our tribal differences-we have done it for centuries.
The question of scarcity is what divides us.The
misguided idea that somehow if one our fellow tribesmen are in a position of power, we automatically benefit has to be abolished.It simply isn’t true.For this reason, there is no need to look for satisfaction in the appointment of our tribesmen at positions of power.We all do this.
Kenyans often take notice and even complain about the types of ministerial positions being given to their tribesmen. As if the Ministry of Energy or Defense for example, means charity to whatever tribe the particular Minister comes from.In real sense Ministry of Energy should mean just that, management of the countries Energy affairs-therefore it should be irrelevant who gets the position as long as they are qualified.
But the president himself also distribute this position in manner suggesting favors to particular tribes.For example, appointing Kalonzo as the VP is a favor to the Kamba people and such news is usually received with a euphoria of joy.Why should any position be about favors to a particular community? This system in itself created tribal divisions.Many luos would have loved to see Raila become the president, not because of his ideals, but because they somehow are misguided to believe that his appointment would be of great benefit to Luos.
These are the reasons why Kikuyus of all shapes and sizes rally around Kibaki unconditionally.And of course it feels good to a Kikuyu to see a president surrounding himself with a bunch of Kikuyus known the mount “Kenya Mafia”. To non-kikuyus, these type of arrangements by KIBAKI only fuel tribal resentments.But this pattern would likely be the same if a luo or Kamba man was in power under the same constitution.
On the subject of tribalism, i actually give alot of credit to Moi. Despite him appointing Kalenjins to top positions, i can now see how he really tried to be a Nationalist. Moi never had a crew of Kalenjins surrounding him. His closest known Kalenjin was just Biwott. He had a habit of appointing Kalenjins as Permanent secretaries but even then he almost equally distributed the ministerial positions. I dont remember a single time when Kalenjins dominated Moi’s Cabinet, Correct me if i am wrong. His distribution, even though it wasn’t based on experience, was fairly equal.
Kalenjins on the other hand were always thrilled at the idea of their own leading the country. It was widely assumed that Moi was doing alot for his Kalenjin people.In reality this was a myth,All Moi ever did was build a nice road and an Airport in Eldoret.But even the Kalenjins believed this myth and were content with their poverty problems for as long as one of them was in Power. Soon as Moi left power, reality hit the Kalenjin people. Its just now that they are realizing they don’t even have jobs.They can’t even get tea picking jobs in their own Kericho town as a result they are viewing every other tribe in their land as an enemy.
FROM Without government, i don’t think Kenyans hate each other because of tribe.We do just fine until the distribution of political positions occur.This is where we split as a Nation.
Its time to abandon this style of reasoning.The idea that if one of your own is in power, you are better off, is a myth. It simply isn’t true.
Its not worth dying and fighting to defend your tribesmen who is in power or who is seeking power.Nothing will ever come out of it.
Its however worth dying and fighting for ideals that will eliminate our poverty problem.
68. TK
(10 Comments) | February 2nd, 2008 at 10:30 pm
@Ali, you are so right. Here is another interesting link on the Kenya middle class - http://www.nationmedia.com/dailynation/nmgcontententry.asp?category_id=25&newsid=115914
In the past weeks I have been trying to understand the mood in Kenya before the 2007 elections. See this prophetic link below -
Kenya Coming Fire.
http://bulletsandhoney.wordpress.com/2006/10/10/kenyas-coming-fire/
69. Rolen
(1 Comments) | February 3rd, 2008 at 3:08 am
At last an afternoon spend scouring the Kenya blogs has yielded something promising thanks to M for starting this thread. So far we have read and seen enough of what has befallen our beautiful country. We are all touched. Some of us are deeply challenged. From reading through this forum, I get the sense of many Kenyans who share in my thoughts to rise above the talk and take up the challenge to do something to salvage our country. For now and for our future generations. Doing something in this case means going beyond setting up relief funds and preaching messages of peace. In the wake of the catastrophic events happening in Kenya are opportunities staring us in the face. Opportunities to instigate positive, lasting change that will shape our nation both socially and politically. These opportunities call for travelling “the road less travelled”. They call for thinking “outside the box”.
To M, kenya1, Ali, Edge of Sanity and all other great thinkers in the room, you may want to read this article. It has inspired and challenged me most. “Kenya is crying out for its sons and daughters from all tribes that have been liberated – even if only partially - from the shackles of tribe through an education and lifestyle that reduces tribe to merely the identity tag that it is” says the article. I’m lucky to be liberated and I hear this desperate cry from my country. I’m sure other liberated Kenyans hear it too. We cannot afford to sit around and think it’s not our job. We have to take personal responsibility and commit to do something. I echo and paraphrase Mahatma Gandhi’s words that, “we must instigate the change we want to see in Kenya”.
Over to you Ali, kenya1 et al, does your project aim to respond to this desperate plea? If yes, then I’m in! You can reach me at rolen34 at yahoo dot com. If not I invite other great minds to join me and do something different and great for Kenya.
70. Abelian
(53 Comments) | February 3rd, 2008 at 4:12 am
Count me in into the patriotic project, I am determined to do anything I can to save my land and my people.
Time has come to say enough is enough
71. edge.of.sanity
(1 Comments) | February 3rd, 2008 at 4:57 am
ON THE FALLACY PEACE :
It seems our [narrow] definition of peace is only “the absence of war”. If the UN and the international community aren’t involved then to us everything is honky-dory…Hakuna Matata!
In reality, mandugu na madada,
HAKUNA MATATA…na matata ni meeengi.As evidenced by Ali, Kenya has been ailing for a while and was never really in a peaceful state - AK47s, for one, do not belong on the streets of a peaceful nation or one at peace with itself. By any definition, peace has been lacking in Kenya.
ON THE PEOPLE:
Garbage in - garbage out, is it?
Sad, but the myth has enough truth in it. The government has to show that it’s not the case by proving it i.e. doing it’s job.
@Ali, M & thinkers in the room.
In the spirit of finding answers, indulge me and respond to the following question. If our politicians, like ourselves, have been bred within an inherently damaged population, then wouldn’t it be fair to conclude that Kenyans in general have a problem with each other and it translates into the sphere of politics? After all, we are all cast from the same mold. What event kick started this cycle of hate? It was there long before 1992.
While poverty is the main culprit here, isn’t it in large part a byproduct of bad politics and governance?
ON THE PROJECT:
I’ve set up a Guardians of Peace [a work in progress] where Kenyans can continue to promote peace, share their positive messages, encourage brotherhood and sisterhood and recognize those who have risen above the madness in their own way since the politicians won’t. I’m looking to catalog the sanity, love, compassion, reconciliation of ordinary Kenyans.
To that end, I seek any stories that reinforce the fact that most Kenyans want peace [by all definitions] unity and prosperity and the first step is to end the violence. From there it will be a long difficult road towards true peace.
I might be going about it the wrong way so any ideas are welcome. The idea is to find information that defies the perceived [or actual] truism in Kenya.
Let me know - kenyanvoices@gmail.com
Thank you
——
I.am.H
72. shujaa 00
(5 Comments) | February 3rd, 2008 at 5:26 am
@ALI
on your post #64.
wewe ni mhenga, umenena vilivyo.its good to see and read such level headedness and to deal with the ISSUES at hand and not just idle banta(no pun intended to everyone else)this is a good blogg.for those that think that bloggz just have storos, i believe there is wealth in issue oriented discussions.we help open each others eyes.i still believe that the biggest atrocity to have hit kenya started in 1963.when tribe came before country.that is our biggest loss and until COUNTRY WILL COME BEFORE TRIBE then we shall forever remain in this hole that we keep digging every second.
73. kenya1
(5 Comments) | February 3rd, 2008 at 10:21 pm
“Let Annan do his bit but there’s going to be no resolution - the clashes will continue”
Lefty
Youth in Kericho
I pulled the above quote verbatim from BBC and it just goes to show the urgency of such a project. The words of a misguided youth in this case are coming off as representing the views of millions of voiceless people in Kericho. Where are the quotes from the people who beg to differ? Why only report from Kenya when some clashes occur? isn’t relative calm newsworthy? While at it, why not also interview people when its calm and people are thinking clearly?
And this coming from the BBC who ought to know better.
It’s up to us people. We have to save the PEACE ourselves. If anyone is interested please send in suggestions, comments, stories or whatever to kenyanvoices@gmail.com. This is a learning project and we don’t have the answers, but together we can solve this problem.
http://guardians-of-peace.blogspot.com/
Thinker,
can you give the above blog some shine on yours?
74. Ken Thumbi
(3 Comments) | February 6th, 2008 at 8:30 am
“the main problem is not our leaders. The problem has to be us the people. The leaders come from among us and are only a reflection of ourselves.
Our minds are not right.”
M, that statement got me weeping, two words “spot on”